Investors often think of stimulative central bank policies as boosters for gold. But the European Central Bank's newly announced 60 billion euro ($67 billion) per month quantitative easing policy could be a bit different, traders argue.
The reason the Federal Reserve's late QE program was thought to be helpful for gold was that it would hurt the value of the U.S. dollar by creating inflation. It would consequently take more dollars to buy gold; in other words prices would go higher.
The massive inflation predicted by some gold lovers never did arrive, but it is true that the U.S. enjoys higher inflation than much of the world, with core inflation measures running between 1.5 percent and 2 percent.
Similar thinking could lead to gold buying on the ECB QE program—after all, more money is being created and pumped into the system, which should stoke inflation. However, the money created is not dollars, but euros. Consequently, the dollar has risen sharply against the euro, which should hurt gold, all other things equal.
And in fact, while gold initially rose to a five-month high shortly after the European QE announcement, it has subsequently retraced much of those gains, as the U.S. dollar has continued on its path higher.
"What you saw was uncertainty about what the ECB was going to do—I think that's what lifted gold higher. But I think now that this is all going to kind of settle down," Anthony Grisanti of GRZ Energy said Thursday on CNBC's "Futures Now." "I don't understand why you would think something that would strengthen our dollar would strengthen gold at this point."
Of course, gold is responsive to more than the price of the dollar. And as INTL FCStone metals analyst Edward Meir points out, gold has been rallying alongside the dollar over the past few weeks.
"The relationship doesn't always hold. There is a disconnect at times, and I think this is one of these times," he said.
Meir says economic uncertainty stemming from the collapse in oil prices and the upcoming Greek election are providing a positive environment for gold, with "the charts suggesting a move up to $1,320," which is about 2 percent above Friday morning prices.