Investors should hedge their stock portfolios because the will probably have one of its weakest years of the current bull market, strategist David Kudla said Thursday.
He anticipates the index will end the year 4 to 5 percent up, at most.
"We're running up against valuation issues. We're in an earnings trough now," said the CEO and chief investment strategist of Mainstay Capital, which manages more than $2 billion in assets.
"That's why investors need to look behind the S&P 500 for opportunity. The indexers are just not going to do well this year."
Read More Stock market highly valued: Vanguard CEO
However, he wouldn't advise investors look to bonds instead. He said the markets have entered a period where stocks, bonds and real estate investment trusts are all declining at the same time.
Instead, Kudla likes alternative investments such as hedge fund strategies packaged in an ETF or mutual fund for retail investors.
Dan McMahon, director of equity trading at Raymond James, said he's expecting a little bit more market volatility.
"We've been range bound for a long, long while," he said, also on "Closing Bell."
Because he expects a rising rate environment, he would stay away from rate-sensitive names, which have recently seen a selloff.
McMahon also doesn't expect oil to go much higher, despite its recent rally.
"This seems to be just a sentiment rally, no real technical fundamental reasons behind it," he said.
"We expect more downside before upside in oil."
—CNBC's Stephen Desaulniers contributed to this report.