"I think [the battery] is greatly overvalued because having batteries as backup storage has been around for hundreds of years," Lutz said in an interview on CNBC's "Squawk Box." "I can't understand the fascination with this."
Lutz made his remarks ahead of a speech by Tesla CEO Elon Musk at the Edison Electric Institute convention in New Orleans.
Tesla shares have risen nearly 25 percent since the company unveiled the Powerwall, a home battery.
Still, Lutz said he believes the company remains unprofitable since its car business is "infinitely small."
"The company is also hemorrhaging cash," he said. "I'm not recommending 'sell' because I'm not an analyst, but if I was a holder, I would think that this is the top the stock's going to [reach]."
Tesla's stock rose 2.9 percent Monday.