Careers

The most underrated and overrated jobs of 2015

How does your job rank?

Nicolas Hansen | Vetta | Getty Images

Being an architect or an event coordinator may seem glamorous, but long hours and low pay make them among the most overrated professions of 2015, according to a report released Friday by job-search site CareerCast.com.

"These jobs have a positive public perception but a less attractive reality," said CareerCast content editor Kyle Kensing. "While they may have high-salary potential, excitement and glamour, there are trade-offs ... that can include long hours, high pressure and stiff competition for positions or clients."

"Often it's a trade-off between how much stress you want and how much income you want," noted Nicole Smith, chief economist at Georgetown's Center on Education and the Workforce. "Unless you have the appropriate level of interest, the late nights and weekends you have to work will be unsatisfying."

Accountants, engineers and human resource managers may lack the same cachet, but they also tend to lack the stress and long hours, making them among the most underrated, according to CareerCast's report.

Overrated professions were chosen from a CareerCast ranking of 200 jobs that factored in job-related stress, competition, industry volatility and high job turnover, among other factors. Underrated jobs all share potential for advancement, a favorable hiring outlook, job security and low stress.

Here are the five most underrated and five most overrated jobs of 2015.

By Jessica Dickler, special to CNBC.com
Posted 25 September 2015

The 5th most underrated job

Doug Berry | E+ | Getty Images

Accountant

Annual median salary: $63,550

Growth outlook: 13 percent

Accountants work with individual clients and large and small organizations to prepare financial records and ensure that taxes are paid properly and on time. It's a job that isn't going anywhere and, despite the stress around tax deadlines, pays well and has plenty of employment opportunities.

"It is portrayed as one of the most boring jobs," said Glassdoor's Dobroski, "but with an increasing number of multinational companies on the scene and more companies going public, I know some accountants that would argue against that."

The 4th most underrated job

Keithfrith | Getty Images

Environmental engineer

Annual median salary: $80,890

Growth outlook: 15 percent

With a background in engineering and science, environmental engineers can work on everything from recycling, water and air pollution to public health. "Environment engineers tie into the future of energy and are necessary for everyday life," Kensing said.

The 3rd most underrated job

Geologists studying graphical display of oil and gas bearing rock on screens.
Monty Rakusen | Getty Images

Geologist

Annual median salary: $90,890

Growth outlook: 16 percent

These days, expertise in the composition and structure of the Earth is highly sought after, particularly from energy companies with a growing interest in fossil fuels. That makes geology a gig in "high demand from firms with deep pockets," said CareerCast's Kensing.

The 2nd most underrated job

Image Source: GaryAlvis | E+ | Getty Images

Civil engineer

Annual median salary: $79,340

Growth outlook: 20 percent

Civil engineers design, supervise and maintain large infrastructure projects from railroads to roller coasters. It's exciting but highly technical, so the competition for talented candidates is stiff.

"Engineering firms lure employees with generous benefits, like childcare and gym memberships, in hopes of attracting the best and the brightest," said Georgetown's Smith, making this career a win-win for qualified candidates.

#1 most underrated job

Brankica Tekic | Getty Images

Human resource manager

Annual median salary: $99,720

Growth outlook: 13 percent

Human resource managers work with top executives on strategic planning and spearhead the recruiting, interviewing and hiring of new staff—all in a typically 40-hour workweek.

"None of your favorite characters in movies are human resource managers, but it's certainly a great job to have going forward," said Glassdoor's career trends analyst Scott Dobroski, "especially now as many companies staff up after the recession."

The 5th most overrated job

Alistair Berg | Digital Vision | Getty Images

Architect

Annual median salary: $73,090

Growth outlook: 17 percent

Architects design and plan the construction of houses, offices and public buildings for clients large and small. "It requires a lot of pricey schooling but pays relatively little," Kensing said. "And it's very much tied to the ebbs and flows of the economy, particularly construction, which was the hardest hit during the recession."

The 4th most overrated job

Laflor | Getty Images

Advertising account executive

Annual median salary: $115,750

Growth outlook: 12 percent

Advertising account execs work with clients to generate interest and sales for a product or service. But it's not all Super Bowl ads and clever commercials, Dobroski noted. It's a highly strategic, high-pressure job. And if an ad campaign misses the mark, the ad exec is left holding the bag.

The 3rd most overrated job

Jetta Productions | Getty Images

Event coordinator

Annual median salary: $45,810

Growth outlook: 33 percent

Behind that invite comes a host of decisions, from food to transportation, all precisely predetermined by an event coordinator. Coordinators work on location and at night, on weekends and even over holidays—all while turning a bare-bones vision into a tangible event that must go off without a hitch, CareerCast's Kensing said. Talk about stress.

The 2nd most overrated job

Highwaystarz-Photography | Getty Images

Sales representative (wholesale)

Annual median salary: $51,670

Growth outlook: 9 percent

Often on the road, most sales representatives in a wide range of industries work long hours with extensive travel and earn the bulk of their salary from commissions.

"If the economy is in a downturn and you don't make your numbers, that will be reflected in a lower salary through no fault of your own," cautioned Georgetown's Smith.

The #1 most overrated job

DreamPictures | Stone | Getty Images

Broadcaster

Annual median salary: $29,790

Growth outlook: 2 percent

Reporting the news at 4 a.m., 11 p.m. and anytime in between, broadcasters can work long and unpredictable hours—especially as they're rising up the ranks—for little pay. They also face intense pressure and extremely tight deadlines. And it's a very competitive field with few job openings.

"This is a job that's glamorized to the nth degree," Glassdoor's Dobroski said. "But for 95 percent of the people in this job, it is anything but."