Futures Now

This statistic suggests a 90% chance stocks will fall: BofA

BofA: Don't bet on a Q4 rally

Suddenly, stocks are hot again, with the is on track for its best week of the year. The index has rallied nearly 5 percent since the start of the fourth quarter, but if history is any indication, the recent rally could soon fade into the abyss.

"If you look at the seasonal data, it suggests we will see a more lackluster [quarter] than usual," technician Stephen Suttmeier told CNBC's "Futures Now" on Thursday.

According to Suttmeier, since 1928 the last quarter of the year has a tendency to be "quite bullish" with the S&P 500 posting an average return of 2.61 percent in the 87 years. However, things could take a different turn this time around.

Read MoreDow closes above 17K for first time since August

"Bullish fourth-quarter seasonals do not work this year," said Suttmeier. "When the market has been lower through the third quarter, the fourth quarter tends to follow on that weakness," added Bank of America Merrill Lynch's technical research analyst. In the 30 instances where the market was negative at the start of the fourth quarter, Suttmeier noted that the average return was down nearly 1 percent.

"The other thing that is interesting is when you take those 30 observations, where you are down through the third quarter, you only end up on the year about 10 percent of the time." The S&P 500 is down more than 2 percent year to date.

Read More The market is 'off to the races': Ralph Acampora

If the recent rally were to continue, Suttmeier said, the market must break through key resistance levels in order to maintain momentum. He identifies these areas as the September 17 high of 2,020 and the falling 200-day moving average which comes in at 2,062. If the S&P 500 continues to trade below those levels it presents "a big risk that we have a bearish shift in trend that we need to pay attention to."

The S&P 500 closed Thursday around 2,010, nearly 1 percent higher.