Crude Realities

How cheap oil raises political risks in Saudi Arabia

MyLoupe | UIG | Getty Images

Saudi Arabia's rulers have long maintained stability with the help of welfare spending and subsidies. But as the oil dependent country's crude revenues sink, the world is watching for political troubles.

Social unrest in Saudi Arabia is unlikely to ratchet up significantly in the next few years, analysts tell CNBC. But if crude prices remain low, and Saudi finances continue to deteriorate, King Salman bin Abdulaziz may find it more difficult to tackle civil unrest in the future.

Falling revenue could exacerbate dissatisfaction among religious minorities, the upper class, or royals, analysts said.

Read MoreWhy OPEC's plan to balance oil markets backfired

Saudi Arabia is the chief architect of OPEC's policy of maintaining crude output at roughly 31 million barrels per day, a level that has forced producers of higher-cost hydrocarbons — including the United States and Russia — to balance an oversupplied market through production cuts.

But as U.S. and Russian drillers prove more resilient than most industry watchers had expected, oil prices have stagnated, putting pressure on Saudi finances.

On Friday, the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries agreed to continue its current policy, sending crude futures lower. On Monday, internationally traded Brent crude fell below $41, to its lowest price since February 2009.

Last year, Saudi Arabia announced a $229 billion budget for 2015, its largest ever. As a result, the International Monetary Fund projects a 19.5 percent deficit for the kingdom this year.

To cover the gap, the nation has burned through about $91.5 billion of its reserve assets, reducing total foreign reserves from a peak of $746 billion last August to a still-healthy $654.5 billion in September, according to the IMF.

In August, the Financial Times reported that Saudi Arabia was seeking to sell about $5.3 billion in sovereign bonds per month through the end of the year. The Saudis' borrowing ability is considerable, but they could find themselves mired in debt, just as they did in the 1990s and early 2000s, said Matthew Bey, energy and technology strategist at Stratfor.

From a social perspective, one thing to keep in mind is that the perception of Saudi Arabia as a wealthy country is false. You have an increasing number of poorer Saudis in the country who feel disenfranchised in an environment in which the politics of the country are changing.
Hani Sabra
head of Middle East and North Africa practice, Eurasia Group

If low oil prices and high spending persist, the Saudis will be forced to reduce spending on social programs, energy subsidies and education, Bey said. The challenge for the royal leadership will be making reductions in areas that will not elicit social backlash, he added.

Saudi Arabia "is still a security state. It will rely on its social apparatus to manage unrest going forward," he said.

Reached by CNBC, the Saudi embassy in Washington did not have immediate comment.

Read MoreBiggest cash issues for Saudis is getting bigger

A reduction in subsidies would have domestic political consequences, and may affect the royal family's tacit social compact with the country's elite, said Simon Henderson, director of the Washington Institute's Gulf and energy policy program.

Henderson asserted that most Saudis are conservative and do not desire social change. "They look at the chaos in the rest of the Arab world with horror," he told CNBC in an email.

Oil workers conduct a drill in a petroleum well in Lagunillas at the east coast of Lake Maracaibo near Maracaibo City in Venezuela.
Oil prices and budgets:The OPEC countries most at risk

While Saudi Arabia is by no means on the verge of collapse, risks are currently under-appreciated, said Hani Sabra, head of Eurasia Group's Middle East and North Africa practice.

"If you look at the Achilles heel of a lot of countries in the Arab world, they have had a pact with people. You get cheap gasoline and energy, you live in a welfare state, and you don't open your mouth," Sabra said.

Like almost every predominantly Arab country, Saudi Arabia has a Sunni Muslim majority. But it faces ongoing protests from members of its Shiite minority and long-simmering dissatisfaction among Muslims who do not subscribe to the strict, conservative brand of Sunni Wahhabism embraced by the monarchy.

Earlier this year, the BBC documented three years of continuous demonstrations in an eastern, largely Shiite region that sometimes turned violent. Activists frequently cited poor economic prospects for residents in an area that is home to the Ghawar oil field, the largest conventional field on earth.

"From a social perspective, one thing to keep in mind is that the perception of Saudi Arabia as a wealthy country is false," Sabra said. "You have an increasing number of poorer Saudis in the country who feel disenfranchised in an environment in which the politics of the country are changing."

The fractured nature of opposition groups works in the royal family's favor, Sabra said, but the current political climate is also breeding dissatisfaction at the top.

Following his ascension to the throne this year, King Salman named his son, Mohammed bin Salman, deputy crown prince — making him second in line in the Saudi succession — after earlier appointing him defense minister and chairman of the country's economic council.

Need to know: King Salman
Need to know: King Salman

That consolidation stands to exacerbate a structural problem with the growing Saudi royal family, Sabra said. Hundreds of royals are clamoring for a piece of the pie, and with low oil prices and power increasingly concentrated in bin Salman, the pie is shrinking.

If those royals are frozen out, many of their wealthy constituents who once had access to the halls of power could create unrest in the upper class, Sabra said. Within the royal family, the chances of a significant rift remain unlikely in the short- to medium-term, but the outcome has increased from very low to credible, Sabra said.

"I am sure there are divisions in the royal family, but the question is whether groups of princes are prepared to do anything about it. I suspect it may be too late," Henderson said.

Read MoreMeet the man who could be the next ruler of oil market

The deputy crown prince may now wield enough power to weather any challenge to his authority, he added. Only a disastrous oil policy or dissatisfaction with Saudi Arabia's ongoing intervention in Yemen's civil war — the first major act under Mohammed bin Salman — could tip the scales, he said.

Bin Salman's regional posturing is a growing concern in some quarters. Last week, Germany's Federal Intelligence Service, the BND, said it was concerned about Saudi Arabia's foreign policy under Mohammed bin Salman, in a rare instance of public criticism.

"The thus far cautious diplomatic stance of the elder leaders in the royal family is being replaced by an impulsive interventionist policy," Reuters quoted the BND as saying.