Trading Nation

Don’t buy into this ‘complacent’ rally, strategists warn

Are investors complacent?
Are investors complacent?

Where did all the volatility go?

Despite a slew of quarterly earnings misses, the most popular measure of expected volatility in the S&P 500, the , has remained notably tranquil.

"[Investors] think they've really got the world figured out," Nick Colas of Convergex said Friday on CNBC's "Trading Nation."

According to Colas, investors are at ease believing that the Federal Reserve will not raise interest rates anytime soon, therefore pushing aside the possibility that a recession could be on the horizon.

Since mid-March the S&P 500 has risen nearly 4 percent, while the VIX has bounced around within a five-point range in the same time frame — and is more than 50 percent off its highs from February, when the market took a nosedive.

This apparent complacency in the market, Colas says, is simply a byproduct of low interest rates.

"When you have trouble holding even 2 percent on the 10-year Treasury, logically valuations would be higher, because the discount rate is lower, so it is consistent there," Colas said, referring to the negative correlations between interest rates and valuations, as well as between the VIX and stock prices.

"We're all tied up in this package where you have to believe in your heart of hearts that rates stay very low for a very long time," he said. "For the moment, the market feels like it believes this narrative very strongly and is comfortable with it."

But not all traders think a temperate market will last.

The S&P 500 is trading historically "extremely high" levels of 11x EBITDA, "a very high valuation relative to the actual earnings power in the market," Larry McDonald of ACG Analytics said Friday on CNBC's "Trading Nation."

McDonald suggests waiting for another decent pullback in the market before jumping in at these valuation levels.

"Put money to work into fear," he said. "Don't chase complacency."

Futures traders don't appear to think the low volatility will last, either. While the VIX opened Monday trading at 14, September VIX futures traded at 20, which would imply a much more volatile market environment.