logo

The fundamental and technical reasons why Netflix could plunge another 42%

VIDEO4:4904:49
Netflix tumbles on earnings: Buying opportunity?
VIDEO2:3502:35
What’s behind the real estate rally?
VIDEO2:2702:27
Defense stocks play offense

The plunge may not be over for Netflix, which fell more than 13 percent on Tuesday.

Michael Pachter, an analyst at Wedbush Securities, certainly believes so as he pegs $50 as Netflix's 12-month target. While that actually represents a $5 increase from Pachter's prior price target, it implies a drop of about 42 percent from Tuesday's closing price of $85.84.

That drop, says Pachter, will come from a mix of rising prices and increasing competition.

"Netflix made the decision a quarter ago to delay the price increase that was originally scheduled for May 9 and phase it in over six months," he said Tuesday on CNBC's "Power Lunch." "[But] before prices started going up, which was really June and July, people quit."

"The fact is that long-time members are running out of stuff to watch," Pachter said. "We've seen everything, and now that 'House of Cards' and 'Orange is the New Black' are over for the year, maybe we'll go try something else."

The video streaming giant's subscriber numbers certainly reflect slowing growth. Netflix said Monday that while it had forecast adding 2.5 million new subscribers globally during the second quarter, the company actually came up short at 1.7 million.

"[Netflix is] investing so many billions of dollars, literally $7 billion, in original content and in buying rights that they're having to trim what they consider to be the fluff," said Pachter. "I think that means that they're not satisfying everybody, people are looking elsewhere. You have Hulu, you have Amazon, and I think that competition's starting to hit. "

From a technical perspective, Rich Ross at Evercore ISI agrees that $50 is the magic number. That's based on his analysis of a short-term chart showing that Netflix's stock had already been in a downtrend.


"Truth is, this stock wasn't even doing well before today's 13 percent decline," he said Tuesday. "You were down 12 percent already year to date, trailing the S&P's plus 5 percent."

"I can see the stock testing $70 and making its way down to $50 in sort of a worst case scenario," he said.

However, BTIG's Rich Greenfield maintains a buy rating with a price target of $130 a share.

Disclosure: Comcast, which owns CNBC parent NBCUniversal, is a co-owner of Hulu.