×

Apple may lose 'fashion icon' status after trouble at Target, analyst says

Some "disturbing" data points may have left Apple's status at risk, Colin Gillis of BGC Partners told CNBC's "Power Lunch" on Thursday.

The iPhone-maker has faced fresh scrutiny after retailer Target posted a double-digit same-store sales decline in electronics, including a "significant drag" due to a 20 percent slide in sales of Apple products.

"Our guests come to us looking for those products. They're looking for the newness and the innovation," Target CEO Brian Cornell told investors on a conference call transcribed by FactSet. "And we're putting together plans with Apple and our merchandising teams to make sure we're ready to take advantage of that in the back half of the year."

Apple device with Target catalog
Jim Watson | AFP | Getty Images
Apple device with Target catalog

To be sure, for a giant like Apple, Target's sales are "just a blip," said Gillis, "just a little tiny data point across the global landscape."

But the trouble at Target, on top of everything else, could raise the stakes ever higher ahead of the next iPhone, rumored to debut as soon as next month.

"There's some data points out there that are collecting that show that this iPhone 7 may not resonate with consumers the way that investors are hoping it will," Gillis said.

One such data point is recent research about China, where Apple's smartphone growth dipped nearly 32 percent over the past year, according to IDC. That put Apple in fifth place in terms of market share, by IDC's estimate, as local vendors saw growth explode.

That's a concern in a slowing overall smartphone marketplace, Gillis said.

"It's not likely that [Apple's] growth is going to continue forever," Gillis said. "This market could stall out."

If the next iPhone is a similar form-factor and iteration of prior models, it could risk losing its status as a "fashion icon" Gillis said.

"If you think of what company in tech is as close to a fashion status symbol, it's Apple," Gillis said.