In 2005, Ohanian and his co-founder Steve Huffman were working on a business called "My Mobile Menu," a kind of food ordering mobile app. But since the iPhone hadn't yet come out (it debuted in 2007), Ohanian and Huffman were pitching the idea before smartphones were ubiquitous.
"Unfortunately, folks at Y Combinator were smarter than us — or, fortunately, I should say, they were smarter than us, and said, 'No, no, it's too early for this. Don't do it.' They rejected us," says Ohanian.
The day after they were rejected by Y Combinator, Ohanian remembers, he got a call from Paul Graham, a co-founder of the accelerator and a legendary investor in Silicon Valley.
"I was like, 'Hello?' And he was like, 'Alexis, we still hate your idea.' 'Really? You called just to say that? We were on our way back to Virginia,'" Ohanian says. But Graham continued: "'No, no, we like you two. Come up with another idea and we will invest. Whatever it is.'"
The next idea Ohanian and Huffman had was Reddit, and Y Combinator gave the two founders a check for $12,000. Today, 280 million people visit the site every month. (Y Combinator now invests $120,000 in accepted start-ups.)
The rejection, and subsequent encouragement and investment, "changed our lives," says Ohanian.