"What did Starbucks do wrong that I wanted to sell it other than the action in the overall market made me nervous?" Cramer wondered.
Starbucks' earnings last quarter did miss Wall Street's expectations, but listening to Executive Chairman and former CEO Howard Schultz and his successor Kevin Johnson on "Squawk on the Street" the day after
, Cramer heard that business was improving and Starbucks was tackling some of its customer traffic and mobile pay issues head-on.
"Panera Bread had the same problem, and when it was fixed, the stock zoomed. Now, ultimately, Panera got a takeover bid. That's not going to happen at Starbucks. But the stock's resistance to falling does tell me that you can't give it away here," Cramer said. "If anything, you want to be a buyer into the weakness."
The "Mad Money" honed in on this problem because despite Starbucks' strong performance, it seems investors have trouble staying in the stock.
He acknowledged that, like Amazon, Starbucks has had problems that caused some weakness, like its market capitalization being topped by McDonald's, now $119 billion versus Starbucks' $86 billion.
"But what matters to me is that I don't want to be shaken out by this period of underperformance any more than I wanted to be shaken out of Apple during its swan dive at this exact time last year," Cramer said.
So while staying in stocks on days like Wednesday could test investors' skills, patience, and, frankly, blood pressure, Cramer came back to one of his central mottoes to prove his point.
"I don't want to look back at Starbucks like so many look back at Amazon and say, 'Yeah, let's see, I sold that, what was it? It was something having to do with Trump? Comey?'" he said. "I don't want [that] to happen to my charitable trust, because that's not how you invest. It is how you panic, though, and there you go: no one ever made a dime panicking."
Questions for Cramer?
Call Cramer: 1-800-743-CNBC
Want to take a deep dive into Cramer's world? Hit him up!
Mad Money Twitter - Jim Cramer Twitter - Facebook - Instagram - Vine
Questions, comments, suggestions for the "Mad Money" website? email@example.com