World Markets

Roughly $17 billion or more could now flow into Chinese stocks, MSCI exec says

Key Points
  • MSCI said it will add Chinese A shares to its benchmark emerging markets index beginning next year.
  • The index is tracked by about $1.6 trillion.
  • Billions are expected to flow into China's A shares as a result.
Over 200 Chinese large cap stocks to be added June 2018: MSCI
Over 200 Chinese large cap stocks to be added June 2018: MSCI

About $17 billion to $18 billion should initially flow into mainland China's stock market once some of those stocks are added to the key MSCI Emerging Markets Index, an MSCI executive said Tuesday.

MSCI announced earlier Tuesday a long-awaited decision in favor of adding stocks, known as A shares, to the firm's emerging markets index, which is tracked by an estimated $1.6 trillion. As a result, non-Chinese investors that follow the MSCI Emerging Markets Index must buy Chinese A shares to match the updated version of the index.

Due to limited access to the mainland Chinese stocks, foreign investors own less than 1.5 percent of that market, Chin Ping Chia, head of research for Asia Pacific at MSCI, said on a conference call with journalists after the inclusion decision was announced. He estimated $17 billion to $18 billion could flow into Chinese A shares.

MSCI's decision to add 5 percent of the floating market cap for 222 China A shares will eventually give mainland China a weight of 0.73 percent in the emerging markets index. Stocks on the list include Bank of China and Tsingtao Brewery.

Lucy Qiu, emerging markets strategist at UBS Wealth Management, said the MSCI decision should improve short-term sentiment for Chinese A shares. But she estimated that initial flows into China's mainland stock market will be far lower — around $7 billion to $8 billion.

A cyclist goes past a quotation board flashing share prices of the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) in front of a securities company in Tokyo.
Toru Yamanaka | AFP | Getty Images

The Shanghai composite has risen just over 1 percent so far this year, in contrast with 18 percent gains for the iShares Emerging Markets ETF (EEM) and a 9 percent rise for the S&P 500. A share U.S. ETFs such as Deutsche X-trackers Harvest CSI 300 China A-Shares ETF (ASHR) and KraneShares Bosera MSCI China A ETF (KBA) climbed more than 1.5 percent in extended-hours trade.

"We believe our clients will benefit from today's decision to bring Chinese equities into mainstream investment. BlackRock has continued to support all opening of investment in China's onshore capital markets for a number of years," Ryan Stork, BlackRock chairman, Asia Pacific, said in a statement.

China already has the largest weighting in MSCI's Emerging Markets Index at nearly 30 percent, but the index only includes Hong Kong and U.S.- traded shares of Chinese companies. For the last three years, the index giant had decided against adding the mainland traded stocks.

MSCI plans to add the A shares in a two-step process next year, following reviews in May and August 2018. That's partly due to trade limits under the stock connect program that links Hong Kong's stock market with that of Shanghai and Shenzhen, Chia said. The development of the connect program was a major factor in MSCI's decision Tuesday, MSCI representatives said.

"We are very hopeful ... Chinese authorities will continue with the momentum" in opening up Chinese markets to foreigners, Sebastien Lieblich, global head of index management research at MSCI, said on the press call.

If China improves the ability of foreigners to access its markets, mid-cap mainland Chinese stocks could also be added to the emerging markets index, Lieblich said. In that case, mainland China would have a 1.4 percent weighting in the index overall, and he estimated inflows could roughly double to $30 billion to $35 billion.

That said, MSCI noted in the release that trade suspensions in some A shares and restrictions on creating related investment products remain issues China needs to resolve.

There is "constructive and cordial collaboration between MSCI and the Chinese regulator," Lieblich said, noting that the index giant doesn't dictate market changes. "What we are doing is providing feedback from international investors to them."

MSCI on Tuesday also decided not to add Argentina's stocks to the emerging markets index, while saying that country's stocks and Saudi Arabia's stocks would be part of next year's review for inclusion.

Lieblich said on the press call that the oil producing nation's highly anticipated Saudi Aramco initial public offering "will have absolutely no bearing on our decision to include the Saudi Arabia index into the EM index."