Bitcoin may just be a 'dangerous pricing game,' says NYU's valuation expert

Key Points
  • NYU finance professor Aswath Damodaran said bitcoin hasn't proven its usability as a currency yet.
  • It all hangs on whether bitcoin becomes widely used in transactions, according to Damodaran.
  • If not, bitcoin may just be a "dangerous, pricing game."
Bitcoin may just be a 'dangerous pricing game,' says NYU's valuation expert
Bitcoin may just be a 'dangerous pricing game,' says NYU's valuation expert

If bitcoin does not prove its worth as a usable currency, its massive price surge is a "dangerous" game, according to one respected finance professor.

"If you don't believe that bitcoin will ever acquire wide acceptance in transactions, it is time that you were honest with yourself and recognized that is just a lucrative, but dangerous, pricing game with no good ending," Aswath Damodaran, a professor of corporate finance and valuation at New York University's Stern School of Business, wrote in a blog post late Tuesday.

"Crypto currencies, with bitcoin and ether leading the pack, have succeeded in financial markets by attracting investors, and in the public discourse by garnering attention, but they have not succeeded (yet) as currencies," he said.

Change in bitcoin price vs. number of transactions between January 2012 and July 2017

Source: Aswath Damodaran

has more than doubled this year to trade near $2,700 Wednesday, while rival digital currency Ethereum has leaped more than 2,000 percent to around $200, according to CoinDesk.

As digital currency prices have skyrocketed, some on Wall Street have started disclosing their bitcoin purchases and issuing predictions of double-digit price gains or more. However, Elliott Prechter of The Elliott Wave Theorist newsletter noted in July that the surge in bitcoin's price and interest in the digital currency has "dwarfed even the Tulip mania of nearly 400 years ago."

Damodaran, sometimes called Wall Street's "dean of valuation," evaluated bitcoin by comparing it to "fiat" currencies like the U.S. dollar based on how fairly the exchange rate reflects their purchasing power.

"The question that you would need to address, if you are paying $2,775 for a bitcoin on August 1, 2017, is whether you can (or even will be able to) buy $2,775 worth of goods and services with that bitcoin," Damodaran said.

He said bitcoin's high price can be justified if the digital currency becomes widely accepted as payment, especially since by design only 21 million bitcoins can ever exist. High demand for a limited supply of coins will naturally send prices higher.

So far, bitcoin's usability is limited.

"Bitcoin acceptance is virtually zero and shrinking," Morgan Stanley stock analysts said in a July 12 report, "The disparity between virtually no merchant acceptance and Bitcoin's rapid appreciation is striking."

The analysts said that among the top 500 online merchants, the number that accepts bitcoin has fallen from just five last year to three this year.

Part of the reason why few customers and merchants use bitcoin is high transaction cost. Fees have climbed as an increasing number of transactions, which includes investment and trading-related activity, compete for limited processing power on the bitcoin network.

The average bitcoin transaction fee jumped from around 31 cents in December to a high of $5.50 in June and was still near $2 this week, according to BitInfoCharts.

When CNBC tried to live on bitcoin in New York City for a week, only a handful even accepted the digital currency, while costs went up roughly 40 percent due to conversion rates and additional transaction fees.

Living for one week on bitcoin in NYC
Living for one week on bitcoin in NYC

That said, Damodaran does expect digital currencies will soon compete with fiat currencies like the U.S. dollar.

In an exclusive July interview with CNBC PRO, he said that cryptocurrencies have already replaced gold for younger investors "because they don't trust paper currencies."

However, right now Damodaran said he is "hard pressed to find a winner on the current list" of digital currencies.

Of more than 800 digital currencies listed on CoinMarketCap, fewer than 50 have a market value above $100 million. Bitcoin is the largest with a market valuation of roughly $45 billion. For context, that's about the same as the quarterly revenue Apple reported Tuesday.

If digital currency developers don't focus more on encouraging cryptocurrency transactions, "we will have to wait for a fresh entrant," Damodaran said.

The "most enduring part" of this digital currency phase may be the blockchain technology they use, he said, "not the currencies themselves."

— CNBC's Tae Kim contributed to this report.