Modern Medicine

Cancer research breakthrough shows a better way to predict drugs that will work

Key Points
  • A new study used lab-engineered microtumors to predict if cancer drugs will work in patients.
  • It could lead to more effective disease treatments and less patient side effects.
Dan Kitwood | Getty Images

Cancer patients need time and drugs that, over time, are effective. They might have more of both according to the results of a new study by researchers in Britain and Italy.

The study, just published in Science, showed that the creation of what the researchers are calling microtumors can help predict drug effectiveness in cancer patients better than the current standard method of testing the drugs on rodents. Researchers took biopsies from 71 colorectal cancer patients and made "cancer organoids," or cell culture models of cancerous organs. Researchers then treated these microtumors with drugs and observed the effectiveness in the laboratory.

In the past, doctors predicted how effective a treatment would be by growing cancer in mice. This process took six to eight months. The microtumors grow in a 3-D matrix called a matrigel, and the whole process only takes six to eight weeks.

Dr. Nicola Valeri, the lead clinician of the study and a team leader at the Institute of Cancer Research in London, said the results are encouraging for multiple reasons: growing cancers in mice costs more, takes longer, and has lower effectiveness scores.

Drugs that worked in the microtumor worked 88 percent of the time on humans, and drugs that failed in the microtumor failed 100 percent of the time in the patient. Valeri said drugs that work in mice have only proved effective in 60 to 70 percent of human patients.

If doctors can more accurately predict what drugs will treat someone's cancer, they can select the right drugs for the right patients. If they know for sure what drugs won't work, they can spare patients the painful side effects.

"You can avoid unnecessary toxicity to patients who won't benefit," Valeri said. "You can switch to another treatment. You can avoid a treatment that doesn't work."

According to a 2015 research study in the Journal of American Medical Association, many new drugs approved by the Food and Drug Administration don't improve overall survival. The researchers examined 63 indications for approval and found that only 30 percent of them were approved based on overall survival.

Valeri doesn't know when this microtumor testing option will become widely available, but he thinks the medical community is closer than most people think.

"We're putting patients in trials as we speak," he said.

More from Modern Medicine:

Trump wants Koch brothers-backed risky drug agenda to be federal law

Bacteria engineered with sonar can track, fight disease

Nobel-winning research advises not taking an iPhone to bed