Inspector general's report on FBI's Clinton email investigation discredits yet another Deep State conspiracy theory

Key Points
  • The inspector general's report published Thursday discredits another Deep State conspiracy hyped by President Trump and his Republican allies.
  • In its review of the FBI's handling of the 2016 investigation into Hillary Clinton's use of email, the Justice Department found no evidence political bias affected the investigation.
  • Inspector General Michael Horowitz did, however, sharply criticize the conduct of multiple FBI officials.
Devin Nunes
Brendan Smialowski | AFP | Getty Images

Another Deep State conspiracy theory hyped by President Donald Trump and his Republican allies has withered under scrutiny.

In February, it happened with the so-called "Nunes memo" that the White House had hoped would discredit the FBI investigation into connections between Trump campaign advisors and potential Russian agents. The memo, by failing to undermine the basis on which the FBI conducted surveillance, proved to be a dud.

On Thursday, the Justice Department inspector general released his report reviewing the FBI's conduct in its 2016 investigation into Hillary Clinton's use of email. Here, too, Trump and his supporters had openly rooted that the findings would back up their claims that the president has been victimized by political bias from entrenched forces within the government that oppose his policies.

James Comey used his Gmail for FBI business
James Comey used his Gmail for FBI business

The 568-page report by Inspector General Michael Horowitz did not back up their claims. In fact, it showed the opposite.

Horowitz criticized, sometimes sharply, the conduct of multiple FBI officials. He said he was "deeply troubled" by text messages exchanged by Peter Strzok and Lisa Page that demonstrated hostility to Trump. With similar communications, three other officials also "brought discredit to themselves," the IG report concluded.

The IG concluded that the private views of those officials "created the appearance" that bias had influenced their investigation of Clinton's email practices. He did not conclude that bias actually did influence their investigation.

"We did not find documentary or testimonial evidence that improper considerations, including political bias, directly affected the specific investigation decisions," Horowitz wrote.

He criticized former Attorney General Loretta Lynch for an "error in judgment" in failing to cut short an airport tarmac conversation with former President Bill Clinton before the Justice Department had concluded the email investigation. But he did not back up Trump's tweeted suggestion that Clinton dangled favors for Lynch in return for going easy on his wife.

"We found no evidence that Lynch and former President Clinton discussed the (email) investigation or engaged in other inappropriate discussion during their tarmac meeting," the IG said.

FBI Director James Comey.
Getty Images

Horowitz also had sharp words for former FBI Director James Comey, who Trump fired last year. He called it "extraordinary and insubordinate" for Comey to hold a July 2016 press conference explaining the decision not to seek charges against Clinton in the email case.

That press conference "deviated from well-established (Justice) in a way intentionally designed to avoid supervision by department leadership," the IG report concluded. It also found Comey made a "serious error in judgment" by telling Congress in late October the FBI was investigating newly-discovered emails, which ultimately proved insignificant in the probe.

But Horowitz did not attribute Comey's decision to political bias. Most significantly, he did not fault the decision not to prosecute.

"We found no evidence that the conclusions by the prosecutors were affected by bias or other improper considerations," the IG report concluded. "Rather, we determined that they were based on the prosecutors' assessment of the facts, the law, and past Department practice."

FBI agent texted 'We'll stop' Trump from becoming president
FBI agent texted 'We'll stop' Trump from becoming president

None of this will stop Trump from seeking to discredit the merits of special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation into his campaign's interactions with Russia. Before the IG report was released, Trump repeated his claim – which no one has substantiated – that Comey illegally leaked classified information to trigger Mueller's appointment.

The president's GOP supporters lent a hand today, too. Rep. Peter King of New York slammed "the shameful anti-Trump political bias" of Strzok and Page as having cast an "indelible cloud" over Mueller's investigation.

Yet Mueller removed Strzok from the Russia investigation after learning of the agent's improper text messages; Page has left the FBI. The only improper FBI conduct Horowitz identified that mattered in the 2016 election hurt Clinton, not Trump.