Comcast and Disney should stop fighting over Fox and split it up — but they probably won't

Key Points
  • Comcast and Disney could both walk away happy by splitting Fox's assets, yet it's highly unlikely that happens.
  • Fox would need to release Disney from its deal to talk about splitting the assets, preventing a bidding war between the two companies.
  • Disney is actively considering its options, including an increased cash-stock bid, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Robert Iger, chairman and chief executive officer of Walt Disney Co. and Brian Roberts, Comcast chairman and CEO.
Getty Images

The irony of the Comcast-Disney battle to buy the majority of 21st Century Fox is that CEOs Brian Roberts and Bob Iger could both walk away happy. All they'd have to do is split up Fox. And yet, it doesn't look like that's going to happen.

Disney wants Fox's movie studio and owned content properties to boost a digital streaming service that Iger plans to launch in 2019.

"The aim of this combined company is to create even more high-quality content and then to distribute it in ways that consumers prefer and consumers demand in today's world," Iger told CNBC in December.

Billionaire investor Mario Gabelli on the brewing Fox-Disney bidding war
Billionaire investor Mario Gabelli on the brewing Fox-Disney bidding war

Comcast, on the other hand, is most interested in acquiring Fox's international assets — European telecommunications company Sky and Indian media conglomerate Star India. Here's what Roberts said on a call with Comcast investors on June 13:

"We firmly believe that that the truly great media companies of the next century will be large, integrated entities with multiple growth engines across a wide swath of the global entertainment industry. And we believe our proposed acquisition of Fox would not only enhance our domestic positions in distribution and content, but would take us to global reach and additional growth in these businesses."

It doesn't take a fission scientist to come up with a solution — Comcast takes the international assets and Disney takes the domestic ones. And if both Comcast and Disney want Hulu, they can halve Fox's 30 percent ownership.

But it may be too late. There are no talks between the two companies about splitting Fox, according to people familiar with the matter.

That's because Disney had no need to invite Comcast to split the assets when it reached a deal with Fox last year. But Judge Richard Leon's ruling on Wednesday that AT&T could buy Time Warner without conditions changed the calculus.

Now Comcast has overbid Disney by about $9 billion (based on today's movement in Disney shares) for the same Fox assets. If Iger wants to avoid a bidding war and split the assets now, Fox would need to release him from the companies' signed deal agreement. That's unlikely to happen, because it could prevent Fox from getting the highest price for the assets it wants to sale — a bidding war is just fine for Fox shareholders.

Rupert Murdoch, Chief Executive Officer of News Corp.
Getty Images

So even though both companies want Fox's assets for different reasons, and are willing to divest similar unwanted parts like regional sports networks, both companies are now fighting for the whole bundle of assets, including cable stations FX and Nat Geo and Endemol Shine Group.

There are personal relationships at play here, too. Don't forget that Comcast tried to buy Disney in 2004, and the Disney board wouldn't talk to Roberts about his $54 billion offer. And the CEO of Comcast-owned NBCUniversal, Steve Burke, worked for Disney from 1986 to 1998, including a tenure directly with Iger after Disney bought Capital Cities/ABC.

The two companies have very similar market valuations, with Comcast at around $148 billion and Disney at $158 billion. Whichever company succeeds at buying Fox will become the dominant force in media.

Disney is actively considering its options, including an increased cash-stock offer, according to a person familiar with the matter. Given the stakes and the personalities involved, don't expect either company to back down without a fight.

A Comcast spokeswoman declined to comment. A Disney spokeswoman couldn't immediately be reached for comment.

Correction: A previous version of this story misstated the difference between Comcast and Disney's bid because it didn't properly account for the change in Disney's share price on Friday.

Disclosure: Comcast is the owner of NBCUniversal, the parent company of CNBC and

Netflix shares are up 2,400 percent and the rest of the media industry is struggling — here's why
Netflix's strategy is shaking up traditional media companies — here's why