Tech Drivers
Tech Drivers

A Trump attack on an Amazon 'scam' is dividing wealthy Democrats and Republicans: CNBC survey reveals  

Matt Lavietes
Key Points
  • The latest CNBC Millionaire Survey, released Wednesday, reveals a partisan divide over Amazon that reflects President Donald Trump's attacks on Jeff Bezos and the technology retailer.
  • Republicans are more likely to think Amazon is bad for small business, and much less likely to believe that Amazon has been positive for the U.S. Postal Service.

President Donald Trump has made Amazon and its founder and CEO, Jeff Bezos, a repeated target of attacks. It seems to be working, and not just with his base of working-class voters.

A majority of millionaire Republicans do not believe that Amazon has helped the U.S. Postal Service, according to the latest CNBC Millionaire Survey, while a vast majority of wealthy Democrats said the tech retailer has benefited the USPS.

A letter carrier holds packages while preparing a vehicle for deliveries at a United States Postal Service processing and distribution center in Washington, D.C.
Andrew Harrer | Bloomberg | Getty Images

The CNBC Millionaire Survey was conducted by the Spectrem Group in April to assess the investment attitudes and behaviors of U.S. millionaires. It studied 750 Americans nationwide with $1 million or more of investable assets. Respondents were both male and female with political affiliations to the Republican, Democratic and Independent parties.

Trump has lashed out at many companies, most recently Harley-Davidson on Tuesday, but Trump has been fixated on Amazon for far longer. In a series of tweets between late March and early April, he accused the company of paying “little or no taxes to state and local governments” and setting up The Washington Post, also owned by Bezos, as a de facto lobby for Amazon.

The president also blasted Amazon for profiting at the expense of the United States Postal Service, which briefly took a toll on Amazon shares. Trump said Amazon was using the USPS as its "delivery boy" and the practice was a "scam" that cost the Post Office "billions."

In one March tweet Trump remarked, "Only fools, or worse, are saying that our money losing Post Office makes money with Amazon. THEY LOSE A FORTUNE, and this will be changed."

The CNBC Millionaire Survey found that 72 percent of Democrats think Amazon has helped the U.S. Post Office versus only 48 percent of Republicans.

That wide gap between Democrats and Republicans on the issue was partially a function of wealthy Republicans not wanting to answer the question. Twenty-five percent of wealthy Republicans said Amazon has neither hurt nor helped the U.S. Post Office, while another 6 percent said they “don’t know.”

Joshua Tucker, a professor of politics at New York University, said "political cueing" can help explain the political divide on Amazon. “What you’re probably finding is when you have a complex question that people don’t have an opinion on, if they can cue on a political party, they will,” Tucker said.

Tucker said the media attention paid to the U.S. Post Office issue helps explain the wide political divide.

“I would go as far to say that if you had asked this question before any of this discussion of the tweets in the media, you probably wouldn’t have seen this difference,” Tucker said.

A Gallup poll released last weekend found 90 percent support among Republicans for Trump, with many GOP voters remarking that media coverage of Trump compelled them to support the president.

Then-Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump cuts a ribbon during the grand opening ceremony of the Trump International Hotel-Old Post Office in Washington, D.C. in October 2016. The hotel was able to use a tax credit for the rehabbing of historic buildings.
Washington Post | Getty Images

When it comes to another Amazon sore spot — its impact on small business — Republicans are more likely to think the company has been a negative, but not by such a wide margin.

Fifty-nine percent of Republican millionaires and 57 percent of Independents said Amazon has been bad for small business, versus 52 percent of Democrats.

Stephen Ansolabehere, professor of government at Harvard University, said the flow of information from the media contributed to the effect being “limited to that one controversy and not general to Amazon as a whole.”

Trump recently proposed to restructure the U.S. Postal Service and potentially privatize the government agency. The Trump administration said the proposal would cut costs and give the agency more flexibility to compete in the digital age.

The wealthy aren't so different

He disputed the idea that wealth would influence how a GOP voter thought about the issue.

“Oftentimes elites have more facts at their disposal, but they don’t have more sophisticated beliefs than the average person,” Ansolabehere said.

The Amazon-USPS divide runs counter to Republican and Independent millionaire views on broader issues related to technology companies and society.

On the overall economy, Republicans (74 percent), Democrats (80 percent) and Independents (71 percent) believe Amazon makes a positive contribution.

The CNBC Millionaire Survey found that overall usage of Amazon Prime is not impacted by political affiliation, with 48 percent of wealthy Republicans saying they do not use the service, versus 50 percent of Democrats and Independents.