US judge raises prospect of not approving CVS-Aetna deal

  • In an unusual move on Thursday, a federal judge raised the prospect of not approving CVS Health's deal to buy insurer Aetna, which closed earlier this week, during a routine portion of the legal process.
  • Judge Richard Leon of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia objected to what he said was the governments and companies treatment of him as a "rubber stamp" for the deal, noting that CVS had closed its deal to buy Aetna for $69 billion on Wednesday.
Larry Merlo, CEO of CVS and Mark Bertolini, CEO of AETNA appear on Squawk Box on Dec. 4th, 2017.
Cameron Costa | CNBC
Larry Merlo, CEO of CVS and Mark Bertolini, CEO of AETNA appear on Squawk Box on Dec. 4th, 2017.

In an unusual move on Thursday, a federal judge raised the prospect of not approving CVS Health's deal to buy insurer Aetna, which closed earlier this week, during a routine portion of the legal process.

Judge Richard Leon of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia objected to what he said was the governments and companies treatment of him as a "rubber stamp" for the deal, noting that CVS had closed its deal to buy Aetna for $69 billion on Wednesday.

Aetna said in a statement, "It's commonplace for acquisitions to close before this final step in the process is complete, and our focus remains on delivering on the combined company's potential." CVS did not return a request for comment.

The Justice Department did not immediately return a request for comment.

The Justice Department gave its OK in October for the merger of CVS, a pharmacy and benefits manager firm, and Aetna on condition that the health insurer sell its Medicare Part D drug plan business to WellCare Health Plans. The court must approve the agreement between the government and merging companies.

Leon raised the prospect of not deciding on the deal until the summer, or perhaps rejecting it, before setting another hearing for Monday.

I was reviewing your motion, which, of course is not opposed. And I kind of got this uneasy feeling that I was being kept in the dark, kind of like a mushroom, Leon told lawyers for the Justice Department and the two companies, noting that the American Medical Association, among others, had objected to the deal.

I'm very concerned, very concerned that you all are proceeding on a rubber-stamp approach to this, he told them, according to a transcript of the hearing.