Personal Finance

Why Ted Cruz may be holding up major retirement legislation in the Senate

Key Points
  • The Secure Act would expand access to retirement savings for workers by making it easier for small employers to offer retirement plans, give part-time workers access to 401(k) plans and eliminate the age cap for individual retirement account contributions.
  • The bill was passed by the House in May, but the Senate has yet to move on the legislation.
  • One reason: disagreements over whether to include a proposal to expand the use of 529s funds to pay for things like home schooling and therapy for children with disabilities.

When a bill to improve Americans' retirement security sailed through the House last month, it looked like the country was on the brink of the first major retirement reform since 2006.

Then the bill went to the Senate. Weeks later, it still has not come up for a vote.

Known as the Secure Act, the proposal is aimed at enhancing retirement by making it easier for more individuals to save.

Janhvi Bhojwani | CNBC

Key changes include allowing small employers to band together to offer 401(k) plans, giving part-time workers access to retirement plans, repealing the 70½ age limit for individual retirement account contributions, boosting the age for required minimum distributions to 72 from 70½ and expanding access to annuities in 401(k) plans.

The Secure Act was approved by the House on May 23 by 417-3. Proponents were said to be hoping to push it through the Senate using a process called unanimous consent.

That means that the Senate would vote on the House version without making changes.

That hasn't happened partly due to opposition from Senator Ted Cruz, R-Texas. Proposals he supports to expand the use of 529s to pay for home schooling and therapy for disabilities, among other expenses, were dropped from the House legislation.

Other expansions of the 529 college savings program, including the ability to pay for student loans and apprenticeships, remained.

"The retirement bill that unanimously passed in the House Ways and Means Committee included the expanded 529 savings plan package," a spokesman for Cruz said. "Unfortunately, at the behest of special interest groups, Speaker Pelosi removed the 529 expansion from the bill before sending it to the Senate."

"Senator Cruz believes we should add it back in and pass a retirement bill that includes both the Gold Star tax fix and the 529 expansion," the spokesman said. The Gold Star fix would prevent children and spouses of fallen service members from getting hit with unexpectedly high tax bills following recent tax reform changes.

The Secure Act's delay this week prompted a group of retirement industry advocacy groups to send a letter addressed to all senators, urging them to vote on the current version.

"We're talking to all senators about trying to advance the legislation," said Paul Richman, chief government and political affairs officer at the Insured Retirement Institute, a financial services trade association focused on the retirement income industry and one of the organizations that signed the letter.

Changes to 529 plans

For policy watchers, the 529 changes are a surprising sticking point for what's considered some of the biggest changes to retirement legislation since the Pension Protection Act in 2006.

"This is the most active front for 529 legislation at the moment," said Jake Spiegel, senior research analyst on the policy research team at Morningstar. "It does seem kind of odd that it is attached to a piece of legislation that is designed to make retirement saving easier."

Current estimates peg the number of home-schooled students in the U.S at more than 2.3 million, according to the National Home Education Research Institute.

Investing in a 529 plan

But 529 savings plans are underutilized even under current rules, Spiegel said.

In fact, 67% of Americans do not know what a 529 plan is, according to a recent survey from financial services firm Edward Jones.

What's more, using that savings plan for short-term needs such as home schooling does not necessarily make sense, Spiegel said.

"The big benefit of 529s is that the capital gains and earnings are tax-free," Spiegel said. "It's really beneficial if you open up a 529 for your beneficiary when they're first born and then you have 18 years for that money to grow."

Here's how much money you should have saved

What to watch

The National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, one of the signers on the letter sent to the Senate this week, has recently set up a grassroots effort in Texas to try to sway Cruz to let the bill come up for a vote.

"There isn't really a process right now for the Senate to pick up their whole package and do some sort of reconciliation," said Judi Carsrud, the association's assistant vice president of government relations. "So I think it is the Secure bill, the way it has passed the House, or nothing."

Still, the two groups hope the Secure Act will pass before Congress breaks for its August recess.

"We're pretty optimistic that there are sufficient votes in the Senate to pass this with a large majority," the retirement institute's Richman said.

More from Personal Finance:
Retirement bill clears House, moves closer to becoming law
This bill could extend Social Security's solvency
You could soon use your 529 plan on your student loans

The Secure Act would be just scratching the surface with regard to changes that need to be made, said Richard Johnson, a senior fellow in the income and benefits policy center at the Urban Institute.

For example, today's retirees face issues including the depletion of the Social Security trust fund, high health-care costs and less access to retirement savings for low-income individuals.

"This bill is a step in the right direction toward improving retirement security, but it's probably not going to make a lot of difference overall," Johnson said.

How to double your money in the market