Hedge fund manager Einhorn likens Chewy to dot-com bubble poster child

Key Points
  • "For those that think the 2000 bubble was the big kahuna, consider Chewy, which went public in June 2019," Greenlight Capital's David Einhorn says.
  • Einhorn has successfully made bets against companies such as Enron and called the collapse of Lehman Brothers ahead of the financial crisis.
The sock puppet dog stars in a commercial for the company, Jan. 11, 2000, in Los Angeles.
Bob Riha | Liaison | Getty Images

Greenlight Capital's David Einhorn, who successfully made bets against companies including Enron, is likening hot IPO Chewy to dot-com bubble poster child

In his quarterly letter to clients, Einhorn also trumpets a successful short position in Tesla but does not specifically mention if the fund is betting against Chewy.

"For those that think the 2000 bubble was the big kahuna, consider Chewy, which went public in June 2019," Einhorn said.

Shares of the online pet retailer were up more than 2% Thursday, and have soared more than 50% since its public debut in June. Einhorn pointed to Chewy's current debt and market value, which he said is 30 times the value of at its peak, as reasons for skepticism.

"Over its life, chewed through just over $200 million of investor capital," Einhorn said. "CHWY has burned $1.6 billion and counting."

Here's a summary of Greenlight Capital's David Einhorn's Q2 holdings, which went out of business in 2000, became one of the most infamous initial public offerings of the dot-com bubble. It was backed by Amazon and raised $82.5 million but folded nine months after its IPO thanks to deep recurring losses. Part of that was aggressive advertising, including ubiquitous sock puppet commercials.

Chewy did not respond to CNBC's request for comment. Following Einhorn's criticism, Chewy founder and former CEO Ryan Cohen wrote an opinion piece disagreeing with the hedge fund manager's comparison.

"While on a superficial level it is easy to draw parallels between the two highest profile online pet retailers, the reality is that Chewy is a fundamentally bigger, better and different business today than ever was," Cohen said in the op-ed published on Friday.

Greenlight Capital funds returned 5.8% in the second quarter, bringing the year-to-date gain to 17.4%, according to the letter. The fund rode successful bets on gold and GM and a short position in Tesla. Einhorn's hedge funds lost more than a third of their value last year, which he said forced him to reopen the funds for new investments.

Einhorn's letter also revealed new positions in three stocks: Chemours, Dillard's and Scientific Games.

In his early years, Einhorn scored some of Wall Street's best results, including a 32% return in 2009. He also made the most prescient call of the financial crisis — the collapse of Lehman Brothers.

Chewy was founded in 2011 by Ryan Cohen and Michael Day, and now calls itself the "largest pure-play pet e-tailer in the United States." PetSmart, which is backed by private equity firm BC Partners, acquired Chewy in 2017 for $3 billion. Chewy released its first-ever quarterly results in June, and showed narrowing losses that were mostly in line with analysts' forecasts. Sales rose to $1.1 billion from $763.5 million a year ago.

Einhorn pointed to similarities in public statements by the now-defunct and Chewy.

"There is a saying that over the short-term the market is a voting machine and over the long-term it is a weighing machine," he said. "We look forward to a time when there is more weighing and less voting."

— CNBC's Leslie Picker contributed reporting.