Save and Invest

84% of borrowers say student loans are tanking their retirement savings

Twenty20

Every month, there's probably a lot of competing demands on your wallet, such as rent, groceries, cell phone service and health insurance. All of those expenses leave many people wondering: How can I afford to save for retirement now?

That's especially true if you're trying to pay down student loans. About eight in 10 adults with student loans say that their debt is negatively affecting their ability to save for retirement, according to a report on the impact of student loans by the MIT AgeLab and sponsored by TIAA.

About one in four Americans has student loan debt, with the average balance just over $37,000. The average student loan payment is $393 a month, which is almost 20% of the typical American's monthly household income.

But financial experts say that despite the competing demands, when possible, borrowers should not only make room in the budget to pay down their student loans, they should focus on their retirement savings as well.

"Young savers and investors who prioritize paying off their student loan while foregoing saving and investing for their retirement will most likely never catch up and remain behind," says Satoru Asato, a financial advisor with Raymond James.

Why investing early is so critical

The MIT AgeLab report found that 73% of Americans say they expect to begin or increase their retirement contributions once their student loans were paid off.

But most people don't pay off their student loans until their 40s. If you wait until then to start contributing to your retirement fund, you'll lose out a lot of savings potential. That's because the earlier you start saving, the more time compound interest has to work for you. With compounding, you earn money over time on both the savings you put into a retirement account and the growth of your investment, so you're earning returns on your returns.

"Many of us tend to say, 'I'll get to retirement savings later,' or 'I have all the time in the world,'" says Carrie Schwab-Pomerantz, board chair and president of the Charles Schwab Foundation. But that becomes more difficult the longer you wait.

If you're in your 20s and you're making $50,000, by putting at least 10% of your income toward retirement, you should have over $1 million in savings by 65 (assuming you receive periodic raises and market returns of 6%). But if you wait until your 30s to start saving, you have to save 20% of your income to achieve a similar outcome. And in your 40s, you have to save closer to 40%.

Making every penny count is particularly important because Social Security benefits are expected to drop by 2035, so more of your retirement income will need to come from personal savings. For those who make over $60,000, chances are less than half of what you need in retirement will come from the government, says Sean Pearson, a financial advisor with Ameriprise Financial.

"I'm convinced that time travel does not exist in the future," Pearson says. "If it did, there would be a whole lot of pre-retirees coming back to tell their 2019 self why it's critical to balance savings and debt repayment simultaneously."

Start small if you need

Yet setting aside 10% of your income, especially in your 20s, can be a challenge. If you're struggling, experts say to focus on contributing enough to a 401(k) or retirement savings account that you qualify for any employer match offered.

I'm convinced that time travel does not exist in the future. If it did, there would be a whole lot of pre-retirees coming back to tell their 2019 self why it's critical to balance savings and debt repayment simultaneously.
Sean Pearson
financial advisor

Let's say you earn $50,000 and your company matches 100% of the first 3% of your retirement contributions. If you contribute $125 of your monthly income, your company is going to put an extra $1,500 into your retirement account over the course of a year.

"I hear a lot that people don't have room for it in their budget, but you really want to make room — this is free money," says Jessica Goedtel, a financial advisor with Valley National Financial Advisors.

Find a balance that works for you

From a pure numbers perspective, it doesn't make sense to solely focus on paying off your student loans. That's because you're losing out on potential earnings when you're not invested in the market. Plus, the average return you will earn on your retirement investments will likely be higher than the interest rate you are paying on your student loans, says Mackenzie Richards, a financial advisor with Bank Rhode Island.

That said, the financial and emotional impact of student loans should not be trivialized, Richards says. Many borrowers feel trapped, stuck or held back due to their loan payments. This can be especially true if you have a higher-than-average student loan balance.

If that's you, then it may work best for you to put a majority of your money towards your student loans. Those with high interest rates (7% or higher) may also want to prioritize paying down the loan. "That's really going to drag your finances down unless you get it paid off early," Goedtel says.

Consider doing something like an 85/15 split, with 85% of your dollars going toward the student loans, and 15% toward retirement, recommends Nick Bautista, a financial advisor with Clearview Wealth Management.

Even if you choose to prioritize your student debt, still save something toward retirement. That may mean finding ways each month to trim your spending or getting a second job. But figuring out a way to do both is crucial. Getting into the habit of saving for retirement early means it will become second nature to invest.

"If you wait to start saving for retirement, you will lose out on time for your savings to grow, and finding financial independence will be difficult to achieve," says Melissa Ellis, a financial planner with Sapphire Wealth Planning. "By the same token, you don't want to delay paying your debt since the interest will capitalize, extending the time it takes to pay off the debt."

Don't miss: Americans are staying silent on student loan debt—and it's not helping

Like this story? Subscribe to CNBC Make It on YouTube!

VIDEO1:4701:47
How 'Crazy Rich Asians' star Jimmy O Yang looks at money
make it

Stay in the loop

Sign Up

About Us

Learn More

Follow Us

CNBC.COM