- Pivotal Research Group sees Roku, an over-the-top (OTT) streaming device maker, stock falling 55% because it looks "overvalued despite the recent pullback."
- Roku shares dropped sharply on Wednesday after Comcast announced it would be giving free Xfinity Flex streaming boxes to its internet-only subscribers, a direct competitor to Roku's devices.
- "We see dramatically more competition emerging that will likely drive the cost of OTT devices to zero and put material pressure on advertising revenue," Pivotal says.
Pivotal Research Group began coverage of Roku with a sell rating on Friday, saying it sees the over-the-top (OTT) streaming company's stock falling 55% because it looks "overvalued despite the recent pullback."
"We see dramatically more competition emerging that will likely drive the cost of OTT devices to zero and put material pressure on advertising revenue," Pivotal analyst Jeffrey Wlodarczak said in a note to investors.
Roku shares dropped sharply on Wednesday after Comcast announced it would be giving free Xfinity Flex streaming boxes to its internet-only subscribers, a direct competitor to Roku's devices. Comcast previously charged subscribers $5 a month for Xfinity Flex.
"Everyone has realized the living room is too important and the big boys ... with massive leverage are likely to make ROKU growth much more difficult," Wlodarczak added.
Roku's stock dropped over 19% Friday from its previous close of $133.76. Pivotal has a $60 price target on the stock.
Down over 26% this week, shares of Roku are heading toward their worst week of trading since the stock's IPO in September 2017. So far Roku has shaved more than $3.7 billion off its market value this week, dropping to a value of $13.6 billion.
After running up over 330% this year, Roku shares have cooled in September. However, even after this week's drop, the stock is up nearly 690% from its IPO price of $14 a share. The stock has been one of the most volatile among technology companies this month as the battle in digital streaming continues.
Wlodarczak noted that Roku "deserves a lot of credit" for building its business and getting its devices into about 31 million households, with the majority in the U.S. He noted that Roku's strong relationship "with lower-end TV manufacturers" has helped the company gain market share thus far and should "set them up favorably" as Roku looks to expand internationally.
The analyst added that Roku grew in spite of facing competition directly from Amazon, Apple, Google-parent Alphabet and even Facebook. The latter technology giant announced on Wednesday that it would begin offering a new device, Portal TV, that can TV shows.
"The problem going forward, however, is that while the large Internet players have realized the importance of control of the mostly video pipe into the living room, now the players that actually control the dominant data pipe into the household in the U.S. (Comcast, Charter, Altice) have as well," Wlodarczak said.
Comcast's free over-the-top device is a shift that Wlodarczak says "will inevitably be copied by other distributors." His four reasons for this eventual change: It's a retention tool, a potentially significant revenue generator, gives distributors greater control of customers' time and, to top it off, he expects Comcast will drive wider adoption due to it being "the most robust product in the market."
– CNBC's Michael Bloom contributed to this report.
Disclosure: Comcast is the owner of NBCUniversal, parent company of CNBC and CNBC.com.