Invest in You: Ready. Set. Grow.

Pension tension: Should you take the lump sum or trust lifetime payments?

Key Points
  • From 1975 to 2017, the number of pension plans dropped to 46,700, from 103,000.
  • During that time, defined-contribution plans such as 401(k) plans grew to 662,800, from 207,700.
  • For retiring workers who are deciding whether to take a lump sum or lifetime payments from their pension, one consideration may be whether they believe in the company's long-term viability.
Getty Images

For retiring workers who are given the pension choice of a lump sum or lifetime payments, one thing may play into their decision: whether they think the employer will be able to meet its long-term commitments.

And as some companies work to regain their financial footing amid the economic hit caused by the pandemic, the issue may loom larger than usual. 

"That's one of the biggest considerations that employees have when doing this kind of analysis," said certified financial planner Leslie Beck, owner and principal of Compass Wealth Management in Rutherford, New Jersey. "Many have concerns about their company remaining viable."

More from Invest in You:
A majority of Americans have no money saved for children
Here's what you need to know about moving in retirement
How to negotiate the best package for early retirement 

The number of private pension plans — which employers fund on behalf of workers — has been dwindling over time as companies have shifted the burden of retirement savings to employees through 401(k) plans or other defined-contribution plans. 

 In 1975, there were more than 103,000 pension plans in operation, according to the Labor Department. By 2017, that number had dropped to about 46,700. During the same time,  defined-contribution plans grew to 662,800, from 207,700.

One tricky part of making a decision about how to receive your pension benefits is that retirees generally like the idea of guaranteed income for the rest of their life, experts said. This often makes choosing the continuing payments more appealing than a lump sum.

"People look at the risk we've seen in the financial markets this year and say 'I don't want risk, I want steady payments,'" said CFP Chris Chen, wealth strategist with Insight Financial Strategists in Waltham, Massachusetts.

If you want to remain a plan participant, be sure you have confidence in the company's ability to make those future payments. Although the federal Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, or PBGC, would step in if the company could not meet its obligations, it may pay only a certain portion of promised benefits.

CNBC's full interview with CalPERS CEO Marcie Frost
CNBC's full interview with CalPERS CEO Marcie Frost

"If a company goes bankrupt or can't meet its obligations, the last-ditch coverage is the PBGC," Beck said. 

The good news is that in the PBGC's single-employer program, there's a surplus of $8.7 billion. If one of those plans were to fail, the PBCG would generally backstop benefits up to about $70,000 annually per participant at age 65, according to the American Academy of Actuaries. 

"That's where the PBCG should make people feel comfortable," said Linda Stone, the senior pension fellow at the academy.

However, the agency's multi-employer insurance program, which covers the pensions of 10.8 million Americans, is expected to become insolvent during fiscal year 2025, according to the agency's most recent annual report. (Multiemployer pensions are those that serve multiple companies.)

People look at the risk we've seen in the financial markets this year and say 'I don't want risk, I want steady payments.'
Chris Chen
Wealth strategist with Insight Financial Strategists

"If you're in a multiemployer plan and get [a lump sum] offer, it's something to think through ... the guarantees aren't as good as on the single-employer side," Stone said.

The PBGC oversees or pays monthly retirement benefits, up to legal limits, to about 1 million retirees whose plans ended or failed. Just last week, the agency announced it had taken over the pension plan for The McClatchy Company, owner of 30 newspapers, including the Miami Herald and The Kansas City Star. McClatchy declared bankruptcy in February and subsequently was sold to Chatham Asset Management, a hedge fund company. The pension plan covers 24,000 current and future retirees.

There also are some pensions not covered by the PBGC, including state-run or locally run plans.

Opting for a lump sum

If you're eyeing a lump sum — more often seen with a single-employer plan — be aware that the amount offered is generally lower in comparison to the amount you are promised to get, over time, if you were to stay in the plan.

However, because interest rates are generally low, lump sum offers have been bigger than they'd be if rates were high. Basically, when interest rates go up, the guaranteed-income option is higher and the lump sums go down.

Also, if you choose to remain in the pension plan instead of taking the lump sum, keep in mind that the amount you'll receive may be fixed for life — pensions typically don't have a cost-of-living adjustment.

"The amount wouldn't go down in nominal dollars, but it goes down in purchasing power," Chen said.

Additionally, although some pensions offer spousal benefits — i.e., when you die, your husband or wife would continue getting a portion of the payments — there is nothing left for heirs. In other words, your death (or your spouse's) ends the plan's obligations to you.

In contrast, if you take the lump sum, you might have money left over at the end of your life that could be left to non-spousal heirs. Of course, that would involve not spending it all — 20% of people who took a lump sum from either a pension or 401(k) plan depleted the money, on average, in 5½ years, according to 2017 research from Metlife.

Be aware, as well, that if you take the lump sum and don't roll it over to an individual retirement account or other qualified option, you'll pay taxes on the distribution. If you do move the money to an IRA, you'd need to decide how to invest those assets to meet your income needs.

Regardless, any decision should be made in the context of the rest of your financial plan, advisors say. And, again, it's worth making sure you believe in a given company's long-term viability.

"People love their pensions, because they're looking at monthly payments for the rest of their lives," Chen said. "The challenge is that, yes, some pension plans are pretty strong and there's a good chance they'll continue to pay as expected, but not all of them."

The American Academy of Actuaries offers a free resource for anyone needing help with making decisions about their pension. There also is a longevity tool that can help you see how long you may actually live and what that means for your retirement planning.