Cramer's Investing Club: Nucor's stock plunge doesn't reflect longer term potential

Published Wed, Dec 15 20215:34 PM ESTUpdated Fri, Jan 14 202212:51 PM EST

(This article was sent first to members of the CNBC Investing Club with Jim Cramer. To get the real-time updates in your inbox, subscribe here .) Nucor (NUE), a Charitable Trust holding, plummeted Wednesday despite management providing seemingly rosy earnings guidance for the fourth quarter. Profits in the quarter are expected to be a new record for the company, with management guiding earnings per share in the range of $7.65 to $7.75, up from $7.28 in the third quarter. It is rare to see the stock of a company that has been around for 70 years fall 8.6% on news of record quarterly profit, but expectations matter, and the consensus street estimate heading into the announcement was $7.95. Looking out, Nucor provided limited, yet encouraging commentary about their prospects for next year. "As we approach the end of the most profitable year in Nucor's history, demand continues to be strong in most of the end markets we serve," the company said in the press release. "We are confident that 2022 will be another year of strong profitability for Nucor." We note that the current consensus estimate on FactSet calls for earnings per share to drop to $17.31 in 2022 from approximately $23.23 this year. We've been in the camp that the steel market will be more resilient next year than what the market thinks, due in part to the recovery of auto production and new investments in oil and gas. If estimates are proven to be too low and are revised higher, Nucor's stock price should follow in the same direction. Outside of steel forecasts, we like how Nucor is still buying back a ton of stock. The company said repurchased approximately 13.5 million shares at an average price of $111.63 during the fourth quarter and this level of activity should continue next year following the Board's recent approval of a new $4 billion program. And by the way, the company just increased its quarterly cash dividend by 23%. In other capital allocation news, we should point out that on Monday, Nucor reached agreements to acquire a majority ownership position in California Steel Industries