Climate activists criticize BlackRock CEO's support for slow transition off oil and natural gas
- BlackRock CEO Larry Fink says oil and gas companies play an important role in bridging global infrastructures to a decarbonized future.
- Climate leaders, however, reject the idea, saying his view amounts to "making the political choice to reject climate science."
- Fink added that government must play a critical regulatory role. "Businesses can’t do this alone, and they cannot be the climate police," he said.
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink's most recent annual letter called the need to decarbonize the global economy the largest investment opportunity of this generation, but he didn't go far enough in his willingness to transition away from the oil and gas industries, climate activists say.
Fink said traditional fossil fuel companies' global infrastructures are necessary in order to build a bridge toward that decarbonized future.
"The transition to net zero is already uneven with different parts of the global economy moving at different speeds. It will not happen overnight. We need to pass through shades of brown to shades of green," Fink wrote in the annual letter.
"To ensure continuity of affordable energy supplies during the transition, traditional fossil fuels like natural gas will play an important role both for power generation and heating in certain regions, as well as for the production of hydrogen," he wrote.
BlackRock, which on Friday revealed it had surpassed $10 trillion in assets under management, does not have a policy of divesting from fossil fuels.
Some of BlackRock's clients do divest completely from oil and gas investments, while others do not, Fink said. The world currently depends on hydrocarbons, like oil and gas, and "we need to rapidly admit that," he said on CNBC's "Squawk Box," addressing a question from host Andrew Ross Sorkin.
It's Fink's view that an ultimatum for hydrocarbon energy would be unproductive for the climate movement.
"Any plan that focuses solely on limiting supply and fails to address demand for hydrocarbons will drive up energy prices for those who can least afford it, resulting in greater polarization around climate change and eroding progress," he wrote in the letter.
But some climate activists reject the idea that greenhouse gas-emitting energy sources have any role in the conversation.
"Fink is insisting on continuing to prop up dirty fuels like fracked gas and peddling the outdated and dangerous view that gas has a place in the energy transition, despite the scientific consensus that we need to stop expanding fossil fuels immediately," Ben Cushing, fossil-free finance campaign manager with the Sierra Club, said in a written statement.
Moira Birss, climate and finance director at environmental organization, Amazon Watch, said that to include fossil fuel companies in an energy-transition conversation signals that Fink's climate talk is insincere.
"Fink apparently wants to be above the political fray, but by playing nice with those profiting off of the causes of climate change, he's making the political choice to reject climate science, which makes absolutely clear that a rapid transition from all fossil fuels is unquestionably urgent and necessary," Birss said in a statement.
"His opportunistic argument for supporting fossil gas as part of the green transition is flatly contradicted by climate science," added Lara Cuvelier, a campaigner at Reclaim Finance, a nonprofit organization that argues the world's largest financial institutions should move away from fossil fuels.
"Fink is thus providing cover for the building of dozens of new gas plants, which would lock us into fossil fuels for years to come. Moreover, his simplistic attack on divestment obscures a vital lesson: to succeed, engagement must be paired with a clear demand to stop fossil fuel expansion," Cuvelier said in a written statement.
"Given BlackRock's enormous fossil fuel interests, perhaps this truth is just too inconvenient to stomach," she added.
Sorkin asked the BlackRock CEO on "Squawk Box" how he decides whether a hydrocarbon company — that is a company which works with natural gas or crude oil — sees itself as being part of energy conversations and investments in the future.
Fink told Sorkin that blue and green hydrogen technologies need further development — as do technologies to decarbonize steel and cement, and to affordably sequester carbon emissions.
Also, in his annual letter, Fink said government regulation must play a critical role in the evolution of energy markets. "Businesses can't do this alone, and they cannot be the climate police."
"We need governments to provide clear pathways and a consistent taxonomy for sustainability policy, regulation and disclosure across markets."