World Politics

Most G-20 nations condemn Russia for war but China stays silent

G-20 Finance Ministers, Central Bank Governors and other delegates attend the G-20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors meeting on the outskirts of Bengaluru, India, on Feb. 24, 2023. 
India's Press Information Bureau | Via Reuters

Finance chiefs of the world's largest economies strongly condemned Moscow for its war on Ukraine on Saturday, with only China and Russia itself declining to sign a joint statement.

India, which as chair of the Group of Twenty (G-20) economies was hosting a meeting in the city of Bengaluru, was reluctant to raise the issue of the war but Western nations insisted they could not back any outcome that did not include a condemnation.

The lack of full consensus among G-20 members meant that India resorted to issuing a "chair's summary" in which it simply summed up the two days of talks and noted the disagreements.

"Most members strongly condemned the war in Ukraine and stressed that it is causing immense human suffering and exacerbating existing fragilities in the global economy," it said, citing disruption of supply chains, risks to financial stability and continuing energy and food insecurity.

Read more about Russia's war on Ukraine:
Zelenskyy seeks more sanctions on Russia as fighting grinds on
Ukraine prepares for the biggest reconstruction since World War II
Refugees could help Germany, but Ukraine's are needed at home
EU adopts fresh sanctions amid vow to up pressure on Moscow
Canada pledges more tanks, imposes new Russia sanctions
Ukraine's allies pledge fresh aid as Kyiv marks one year of war
Refugee-averse Japan welcomes Ukrainians after Russia war

"There were other views and different assessments of the situation and sanctions," it said, referring to measures put in place by the United States, European countries and others to punish Russia for the invasion and starve it of revenues.

The outcome was similar to that of a G-20 summit in Bali last November when host Indonesia also issued a final declaration acknowledging differences. The G-20, formed over two decades to tackle economic crises, has increasingly struggled to reach a consensus among members.

U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen earlier told Reuters that it was "absolutely necessary" for any statement to condemn Russia. Two delegates told Reuters that Russia and China did not want the G-20 platform to be used to discuss political matters.

Russia, a member of the G-20 but not of the G-7, refers to its actions in Ukraine as a "special military operation", and avoids calling it an invasion or war.

India has kept a largely neutral stance, declining to blame Russia for the invasion, seeking a diplomatic solution and sharply boosting its purchases of Russian oil.

China and India were among the nations that abstained on Thursday when U.N. voted overwhelmingly to demand Moscow withdraw its troops from Ukraine and stop fighting.

Besides the G-7 nations, the G-20 bloc also includes countries such as Australia, Brazil and Saudi Arabia.

Debt negotiations

On the sidelines, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) held a meeting on Saturday with the World Bank, China, India, Saudi Arabia and the G-7 on restructuring debt for distressed economies, but there too there were disagreements among members, said IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva.

"We just finished a session in which it was clear that there is a commitment to bridge differences for the benefit of countries," Georgieva, who co-chaired the roundtable with Indian Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, told reporters.

One delegate told Reuters that some initial progress was made, mostly on the language around the issue, but restructuring was not discussed in detail.

Yellen said there were no "deliverables" from the meeting, which was mostly organizational.

Further discussions are planned around the time of the IMF and World Bank spring meetings in April.

Pressure has been building on China, the world's largest bilateral creditor, and other nations to take a large haircut in loans given to struggling developing nations.

In a video address to the G-20 meeting on Friday, Chinese Finance Minister Liu Kun reiterated Beijing's position that the World Bank and other multilateral development banks should also participate in debt relief by taking haircuts.