So what gives?
Investors may be wising up to how Netflix is going to profitably offer streaming content that can compete with far more expensive cable and satellite subscriptions. Meanwhile, after activists like Carl Icahn have bought up Netflix shares, the company may be entering a new phase of discretion when it comes to paying for streaming video content.
Notably, after signing an exclusive content agreement with Walt Disney for its popular Pixar, Marvel, and Star Wars movies for an undisclosed price, Netflix may not feel it needs to chase every new deal out there, as subscribers await a dramatic expansion of the movies offered on its steaming service.
While Netflix lost out to Universal on the rights to HBO content, it was able to quietly improve the streaming portfolio offered to subscribers by way of a less hyped exclusive deal with Time Warner's or previous seasons of serialized dramas produced by Warner Brothers Television.
"Netflix continues to bring viewers the best content portfolio, and today's announcement only serves to reinforce that," wrote Morgan Stanley analyst Scott Devitt, in a Monday note to clients that reiterated the firm's "overweight" rating.
"With the addition of eight well-known/highly-anticipated serialized dramas on their way to Netflix users' TVs, the company has better positioned itself relative to both Amazon Prime Instant Video and Hulu," notes Devitt. "Additionally, the Warner Bros. serialized TV content may bring new subscribers and reduce churn among existing customers, especially given its exclusivity," the analyst concludes.
In the wake of Netflix's early December deal with Disney, chief content officer Ted Sarandos said at the UBS Global Media Conference that Neflix would focus its efforts on exclusive content deals, and that it would show discretion in only paying up for top programming such as Disney movies or AMC television shows.
At the conference, Harvey Weinstein, the co-founder of Miramax Films and current co-chair of The Weinstein Co. poked fun at flighty Wall Street investors for selling shares when Neftlix didn't renew with Starz, only to see them surge in the wake of a far more groundbreaking Disney deal.
"That Starz deal, when you didn't renew [it], you paid a price," said Weinstein to Netflix CCO Sarandos, in a discussion the famed producer led. "With Disney, does Wall Street realize you became Starz plus Netflix?" added Weinstein of the early December deal.
Sarandos spent the better part of an hour-long presentation emphasizing a focus on exclusive content and even shows like "Arrested Development" and "House of Cards," which will only be seen on the streaming service. Sarandos even indicated that Netflix could eventually make self-produced original content, when asked by Weinstein.
So what does it all mean?
Increasingly, Netflix may be falling into its position as a power broker in the media and entertainment industry, given its existing portfolio of exclusive content.
For investors, it should be no surprise then that like cable and satellite systems such as Dish Network and Time Warner Cable, Netflix expects it can grow subscriber offerings without damaging the bottom line for shareholders.
If Harvey Weinstein saw reason to be credulous of trader instincts when it came to Netflix shares in 2012, maybe 2013 is the year the company proves itself to skeptics.