Why Stock Market Is 'Going to Hit a Brick Wall'

If mom-and-pop investors are always the last ones to the stock party, then it might be time to call a cab.

Market behavior in recent weeks suggest that after years of running from equities, the retail crowd is coming back in a big way.

Money flowed into stock-based mutual funds last week at a pace not seen in more than four years, and sentiment surveys and volatility measures show there is almost no fear in the market. (Read More: Money Pours Back Into Stocks)

Such periods in the past often have preceded ugly times in the market.

(Read More: What Happened to the Wall of Worry?)

"All the ducks are starting to line up," said Robert Sneddon, president at CastleMoore, an Ontario-based global asset allocation firm. "But we're inching along and probably a month away, maybe three weeks (from a market top). You've got several things lining up, pointing us in that direction."

NYSE traders
Getty Images

Most notable among the trends was a near-record pace of fund flows last week into equity funds.

Stock mutuals saw $19 billion come in, the highest since 2008 and the fourth-biggest in the 12-year history of tracking the data, according to Bank of America Merrill Lynch.

The latest American Association of Individual Investors survey registered a 46.4 percent bullish reading during the same period, well above historical averages, while those expecting the market to be lower in six months fell to 26.9 percent.

Finally, the CBOE Volatility Index, or VIX, a popular measure of market fear, is at a subdued sub-14. A declining VIX usually means rising stock prices.

(Read More: Why VIX's Recent Plunge May Be Bad for Stocks)

About the only areas showing caution were safe-haven money market funds, which saw assets grow to $2.72 trillion on an influx from institutions, and commodities, which had outflows of $570 million.

The most popular reason among traders for all the optimism is basic relief that the U.S. made it through the "fiscal cliff" scare relatively unscathed.

If that's the case, the looming debt-ceiling battle and a likely lackluster earnings period could offer perilous counterweights.

"If you want to trade on the headlines you can do that. But if you're looking at fundamentals eventually you're going to hit a brick wall," said Todd Schoenberger, managing director at LandCold Capital.

Earnings season, which just began this week in earnest, is likely to paint a bleak picture of the U.S. consumer, he added.

"Sentiment has improved, but it's completely artificial," Schoenberger said. "You need more than that to sustain any type of rally."

Sneddon said he will be looking for a 2 percent yield on the 10-year Treasury note - currently around 1.9 percent - to signal that the upward momentum for stocks has gotten carried away.

Until then, he said he's adding positions in gold producers as well as utilities and consumer staples.

That strategy of riding the wave but getting ready for a crest is popular.

Michael Cohn, chief market strategist at Atlantis Asset Management in New York, said he's looking for a pullback once the Dow industrials hit the 14,000 neighborhood..

Until then, he's been picking up companies including Southern Copper, Joy Global and Target as well-priced stocks that could ride whatever is left of the early-year rally.

"You've got to wait to be a contrarian," Cohn said. "It's been a benign period of probably decent earnings and no news flow from the idiots who can screw things up."

Indeed, one week does not a trend make, so those bullish on the market believe there will need to be plenty more weeks like the most recent ones in terms of fund flows before sentiment gets too frothy.

"This is showing a lot more renewed confidence from the retail investors that Washington's policies are not going to inhibit a stock market rally," said Dave Lutz, managing director of trading at Stifel Nicolaus in Baltimore. "Just the sheer magnitude of these flows is driving the market. It's a massive tailwind."