Is There a Bright Side to the Dismal GDP Report?

Cloud computing
John Lund | Photographer's Choice | Getty Images

Futures fell, but only a few points, on the dismal fourth-quarter advance gross domestic product report, which came in at negative 0.1 percent, versus estimate of a gain of 1 percent. But as Greg Valliere has pointed out, the strong durable goods report on Monday indicates that "the fiscal cliff didn't inhibit business spending as much as feared." A strong jobs report on Friday — over 200,000, vs. current consensus of 65,000 — should it occur, will go a long way toward reducing the impact of that GDP report.

Well, if there is any bright side to the report, it's that the Federal Reserve is unlikely to make noises about ending its stimulus program any time soon.


1) Earnings keep rising: We started the quarter with fourth-quarter estimates at about 3 percent growth for the S&P 500. Today, with nearly 40 percent of the S&P 500 component companies reporting, earnings growth is at 5.15 percent, according to S&P Capital IQ. Revenue growth, which was essentially zero last quarter, is now at 4 percent.

Some 67 percent are beating earnings estimates (the 12-year average is 62 percent), while 65 percent are beating revenue estimates (the 12-year average is 61 percent). Last quarter, only 38 percent beat revenue estimates.

My main thesis: Earnings growth is not strong, but there are clear signs that the third quarter may have been a trough for earnings.

2) Commodities are strong: I noted a few days ago that the early birds have been pushing the Big Trade (they hope) of 2013 — short Treasurys, go long cyclical stocks and copper.

Today, commodities are indeed moving: Copper is up 1.2 percent; aluminum and zinc are up 2.5 percent, and nickel is up 3.2 percent.

In stocks, the global rally shows no signs of abating. Japan's Nikkei closed at a 33-month high as the yen continues to weaken against the U.S. dollar and euro. Hong Kong closed at a 21-month high.

3) I got some pushback from traders when I noted that builder D.R. Horton reported the average selling price was up 15 percent in their communities ... the pushback implied it was unrealistic to expect these kind of price gains in the housing market this year.

I agree that 15 percent price increases are unlikely nationwide, particularly for existing homes, but 15 percent is not far off for some new homes. Consider that Credit Suisse analyst Dan Oppenheim today raised estimates and target prices for all the builders he covers, and upgraded KBH to "outperform" from "neutral."

The reason: accelerating order growth and margin expansion, largely due to higher prices. He expects home prices to increase 4 percent to 5 percent in 2013, but also noted "our recent community checks in Northern and Southern California suggested prices are up double-digits in many communities. This will lead to meaningful margin expansion."

Meantime, Ryland is at a 5.5-year high after beating on top-line and bottom line last night. Fourth-quarter orders were up 64 percent, but excluding a recent acquisition were up 52 percent, well above consensus of about 40 percent.

Orders are strong for all the big builders: D.R. Horton up 39 percent; Toll Brothers is up 36 percent; Lennar is up 32 percent; and Beazer Homes is up 29 percent. Only KB Homes, at 4 percent, was on the disappointing side.

It did note that construction costs are coming down, which was interesting. However, elsewhere the industry is talking about higher prices for scarcer lots, and a shortage of skilled labor in some parts of the country.

  • Bob Pisani

    A CNBC reporter since 1990, Bob Pisani covers Wall Street from the floor of the New York Stock Exchange.

Wall Street