"[Civic] went from one of the best small cars to one of the worst small cars and we couldn't even recommend it," Fisher said. "So they did an 18 month refresh, they improved that car, but what really blew us away was the Accord. This was the first time in many years where Honda just got it right out of the park and this car is just better than the old model in so many ways."
(Read More: Auto Sales Start the Year With a Bang)
Meanwhile, Consumer Reports picked the Audi A6 as the top luxury car in this year's annual auto issue. Fisher said Audi has finally turned the corner with improving reliability to match its well established reputation for top-notch styling.
"Audi is actually making reliable vehicles—[we] couldn't say that just a few years ago," Fisher said. "So now you have a manufacturer producing these cars that are great to drive, comfortable, fun, do many things well and now they are reliable too. It is a great choice."