Market Rally? Here's Why It Happened

Huh, what happened? With the understanding that we are still midday, here's the reasons for the rally:

1) The primary driver is that stocks have been dramatically oversold, and in the case of financials, heavily shorted;
2) Goldman affirmed they were still the smartest guys on the Street by saying there would be no significant write-downs from mortgage derivative losses;
3) A lack of bad news: no other banks or brokers had anything significantly negative to say (JP Morgan's CEO said "We're fine" on CDOs and subprime exposure, B of A's CFO said losses were "manageable"), and
4) Wal-Martdid not lower fourth quarter guidance.

Bears are not impressed. They point out that:

1) It is common for there to be brief snap-back rallies when markets are in a notable downtrend (these are the classic bull traps);
2) If Goldman says they are not taking write-downs with high levels of CDO exposure, there must be significant counterparty risk out there somewhere;
3) There is plenty of other retailers likely to lower Q4 guidance, and
4) In case you haven't noticed, it's the close that matters nowadays.

Questions? Comments?