Weak Retail Sales Report Could Signal Recession

Whether it's Big Macs, big rocks or big trucks, U.S. consumers are tightening their purse strings, and the squeeze may be severe enough to topple the U.S. economy into recession.

Cash Register
Paul Sakuma
Cash Register

On Tuesday, economists expect the Commerce Department to report flat retail sales for December, and some suspect that the number could be negative as the housing downturn, tougher credit conditions and steep inflation sink household spending.

A negative reading in December would mark the first decline since June.

"December's retail sales update may tell whether consumer spending has the legs to keep the expansion on track," Global Insight economists wrote in a note to clients.


The 'R' Word -- How to Invest:


Economists were bracing for a soft sales report after a host of retailers posted disappointing holiday season sales figures in recent days. Consumer spending accounts for more than two-thirds of U.S. economic activity, which explains why economists pay such close attention.

What they found particularly worrying was the breadth of the slowdown. The bad consumer spending news has come not only from Big Mac maker McDonald's and lower-priced retailers Kmart and Sears, but also luxury chains such as jeweler Tiffany.

"We believe a recent pullback in U.S. spending likely reflected a more cautious attitude among consumers about the near-term direction of the economy," Tiffany CEO Michael Kowalski said last week.

Monday, Ford Motor said that industrywide auto sales would likely dropin the first half of 2008.

U.S. recession talk picked up after disappointing data on December employment and manufacturing, and a subpar holiday shopping season has added to the gloom.

Sales may suffer more in the coming months as tightening credit conditions spread beyond the housing market and into credit cards, the crutch that has increasingly supported consumer spending as mortgage refinancing slows.

"In the easy housing money years, consumers were racking up debt on their credit cards, then rolling that debt into lower-interest home equity loans or using cash-out refinancings to pay down the higher interest rate credit card debt," said Gary Balter, retail sector analyst with Credit Suisse.

"With that safety net no longer available, credit card balances are growing sharply, increasing debt servicing costs. Consumers are struggling to meet these costs, evidenced by mounting credit card delinquencies and losses."

Credit card debt jumped by 11.3 percent to $937.5 billion in November, according to Federal Reserve data.

Credit card company American Express warned last week that delinquencies were on the rise, particularly in California, Florida and other regions hardest hit by the housing downturn.

Credit Suisse's Balter said credit card issuers were tightening lending standards as their own borrowing costs rose, an increase that comes despite a series of Fed interest rate cuts that have shaved a full percentage point off the benchmark federal funds rate since mid-September.

Nervousness in the asset-backed securities market, where consumer loans are typically packaged and sold to investors, has raised costs for credit card issuers, and they will likely
try to recoup that by charging customers more, Balter said.

"We are already seeing the impact of tougher mortgage standards on the housing market," Balter said. "With credit card delinquencies rising and securitizations tougher to do, we
worry when that shoe will drop, further impacting retail spending."

Balter lowered investment ratings and stock price targets on a host of retailers Monday. Goldman Sachs Monday also took a dimmer dimmer view of retailers across the price spectrum, from handbag maker Coach to Sears, owner of Kmart and Sears stores.

Even the retailers' trade association said 2008 looked less than rosy. The National Retail Federation said retail sales would likely grow 3.5 percent from a year earlier, the slowest
pace in six years.

"We don't know whether it will be a recession or not," NRF Chief Economist Rosalind Wells said. "It's just not going to feel good to anyone."