A failure to deliver on its implicit promise of tighter monetary policy could lead to increased financial market volatility and derail the tentative calm that aggressive Fed action has managed to inspire.
Futures markets have already begun pricing in chances of an interest rate hike as early as September, a prospect that many analysts think is far-fetched given the still-shaky state of housing and finance.
"They are threatening at the moment but I don't think they'll really pull the trigger," said Chris Rupkey, senior financial economist at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi, who was speaking on the sidelines of a Fed conference on inflation on Cape Cod.
The about-face in Fed speak has come abruptly. Just a month ago, most officials seemed keenly focused on the risk that economic growth would slow even further, buried under the weight of falling home values and rising energy costs.
But in a series of recent speeches, Fed chief Ben Bernanke appears to have tilted the prevailing discourse toward the central bank's more hawkish camp.
On Monday,Bernanke said the Fed would work to restrain consumer expectationsof higher prices. He also played down a May surge in the unemployment rate from 5 percent to 5.5 percent, the biggest jump in 22 years, saying the risks of a substantial downturn in the U.S. economy had receded.
"The Federal Open Market Committee will strongly resist an erosion of longer-term inflation expectations, as an unanchoring of those expectations would be destabilizing for growth as well as for inflation," Bernanke said.
The trouble, according to many investors, is that the Fed's hands are tied.
"Is there enough life left in the patient in the wake of the housing and credit bust and the oil shock that would allow the Fed to heap further stress on the host?" asks William O'Donnell, head of U.S. interest rate strategy at UBS Securities in Stamford Connecticut. "We think not and we think that words will have to suffice.
The weakness of the dollaris also a central issue for the the Fed and is part of the reason the central bank has stepped up its rhetoric on inflation.
Rock and A Hard Place
The Fed is worried record-high energy costs could lead consumers to expect a swift inflation pace is here to stay, setting in motion a self-feeding wage-push inflation cycle.
Indeed, some data suggest inflation expectations are already on the rise. The Conference Board said its survey of consumers showed inflation expectations hit an all-time high of 7.7 percent last month.
Now that the average price of a gallon of gasoline has hit a record above $4 a gallon, expectations could climb further.
Still, many economists say a wage-price cycle is unlikely to develop, given the weak state of the economy. Over the past year, the rise in average hourly earnings has slowed.
At the same time, the swooning housing market has shown few signs of life. Home prices have fallen 14 percent over the past year by one measure, cutting many homeowners off from the equity they had tapped for spending during the housing boom.
At the same time, financial institutions continue to report large write-downs related to complex investments in the real estate sector. Fears have been running high that Lehman Brothers
could face a run on the bank similar to the one that brought Bear Stearns to the brink of bankruptcy in March.
Given these weak spots, many analysts just do not think it feasible for the Fed to act against inflation by boosting rates, particularly in a presidential election year when such an action could generate unwanted political reverberations.
Indeed, Bernanke signaled last week that the central bank would likely remain on the sidelines for some time, describing policy as "well-positioned."
"We still think no Fed tightening for a good while," said Andrew Brenner, senior vice president at MF Global in New York.
Futures markets are seeing it differently, however. By Tuesday, they had priced in a series of rate increases beginning in September that would take benchmark overnight rates up three-quarters of a percentage point by year end.
These conflicting expectations could come to a head later in the year, analysts say, exacerbating market fluctuations that have already been extreme. Oil prices recently posted their largest-ever one-day spike, while 2 percent moves in either direction have become commonplace for the stock market.
Nonetheless, such troubles might be avoided altogether if the Fed's jawboning efforts are successful at reigning in inflation expectations.
They have already proven so in the very near term, with the spread between nominal and inflation-protected bonds narrowing in the wake of Bernanke's comments.