“It gives investors a false sense of security,” Kilduff told CNBC.
“As good as this trade can be, I’ve seen it go the other way.”
Kilduff said while the "widowmaker" can make a good trade for some players, he remains leery.
“There’s a lot of momentum it can really run, but there are some things weighing on it—whether or not the consumer can withstand $3 a gallon,” said Kilduff. “The consumers are much more damaged than in 2007, when they were able to pay $4 a gallon before we saw any resistance.”
- RBOB Gasoline Futures Now
Kilduff also said he expects crude oil to soar to $100 a barrel before July.
Counterpoint: Room to Run
On the other hand, Armstrong said there’s further room to run in the widowmaker trade.
“The spread is out to about 16 cents, which is not nearly as wide as it got two years ago when it got to 50 cents,” he said.
“I’m not sure you’re going to see 50 cents on it like you did before, but if you get 26 cents from 15, you’ve got a nice profit on it.”
In terms of crude oil prices, Armstrong said if prices hold at above $80, it could rise further and test the $85 to $90 levels. Otherwise, he said he sees prices falling back down to $70.
- Light, Sweet Crude Futures Now
- Heating Oil, Natural Gas and Uranium
More Market Intelligence:
CNBC Data Pages:
Top Oil Firms:
No immediate information was available for Armstrong or Kilduff.