Kaminsky's Call: Why Buybacks Traditionally Don't Work

As we discussed on The Strategy Session yesterday, investors and analysts alike are enthusiastic whenever they hear of a new stock buyback.

Hewlett-Packard's headquarters in Palo Alto, California.
Hewlett-Packard's headquarters in Palo Alto, California.

The big one this month is Hewlett-Packard and their $10 billion plan to spend cash in this manner.

If you go by history, this is a bad move. My "Call-to-Action" is directed towards (HPQ) holders and those considering the stock; know that buybacks traditionally don't work and act accordingly.

There are so many ways a company can deploy cash whether it be to grow their business organically, hire more people, or pay back in dividends and distributions.

What value have buybacks given investors? We looked at three poor performers on the show yesterday.

Microsoft's $40 billion, Intel's $25 billion, and, most notoriously, AT&T's $15 billion buybacks gave back no value to investors. The first two took years to get back to levels where the buyback was announced. AT&T's was nothing short of a disaster as the stock did nothing but plunge after a very short-lived initial boost.

What is the reason for these failures?

Companies, for the most part, have terrible sense of timing when and, strategically, why they announce buybacks. Imagine if tech, media, and telecom companies had just bought Apple stock instead. The results would be otherworldly compared to the mediocre-to-poor performances we just evaluated.

If I owned a stock in a company, I would rather see cash given back in the form of distributions. Put the capital in the hands of the investors.

Hewlett-Packard is trying in various ways to compensate for the Mark Hurd debacle. This is not one of the right ones. Be wary of this buyback's chances for success.

Programming note: "The Strategy Session," hosted by David Faber and Gary Kaminsky, airs weekdays at Noon ET on CNBC.

Gary Kaminsky does not hold any equity positions.

The content of this blog is published in the United States of America and persons who access it agree to do so in accordance with applicable U.S. law.

All opinions expressed in this blog are solely the opinions of Gary Kaminsky and do not reflect the opinions of CNBC, NBC UNIVERSAL or their parent company or affiliates, and may have been previously disseminated on television, radio, internet or another medium. You should not treat any opinion expressed by Mr. Kaminsky as a specific inducement to make a particular investment or follow a particular strategy, but only as an expression of his opinion. Mr. Kaminsky’s opinions are based upon information he considers reliable, but neither CNBC nor its affiliates and/or subsidiaries warrant its completeness or accuracy, and it should not be relied upon as such. Mr. Kaminsky, CNBC, its affiliates and/or subsidiaries are not under any obligation to update or correct any information provided on this website. Mr. Kaminsky’s statements and opinions are subject to change without notice. No part of Mr. Kaminsky’s compensation from CNBC is related to the specific opinions he expresses.

Past performance is not indicative of future results. Neither Mr. Kaminsky nor CNBC guarantees any specific outcome or profit. You should be aware of the real risk of loss in following any strategy or investment discussed on this website or on the show. Strategies or investments discussed may fluctuate in price or value. Investors may get back less than invested. Investments or strategies mentioned on this website or on the show may not be suitable for you. This material does not take into account your particular investment objectives, financial situation or needs and is not intended as recommendations appropriate for you. You must make an independent decision regarding investments or strategies mentioned on this website or on the show. Before acting on information on this website or on the show, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and strongly consider seeking advice from your own financial or investment adviser.