Housing Demand Defies Fundamentals

David Calvert | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Anyone with any cash in hand should be buying a house right now.

That’s what any real estate agent will tell you, obviously, but that’s also what many investors now believe.

Unfortunately, the potential home-buying public…isn’t buying it.

January’s consumer confidencereport found a drop in the number of Americans who plan to buy a home in the next six months. If, however, you take out the confidence issue, the fundamentals for buying are strong:

Home prices nationally are down 33 percent from their bubble peak, according to the latest S&P/Case-Shiller report, mortgage rates are hovering near record lows, and housing supply, while falling, is still historically high. In other words, it’s more of a buyer’s market than it’s ever been.

And yet the home ownership rate continues to fall, and rental demand, occupancies and rates continue to rise.

“Federal plans to sell real estate owned propertiesto investors might provide some relief, but rental value growth is still likely to hit 3 percent this year and average rental yields may rise to around 5.5 percent,” wrote Paul Diggle of Capital Economics, who believes the downturn in homeownership may still have further to run.

Both Diggle and Standard and Poors’ David Blitzercite still tight credit as the major obstacle to housing demand. Rates are low, but to get those rates you need a significant down payment. The low down payment route, the FHA, has raised fees and premiums, which for some are a barrier to entry. A full third of the market is now all-cash.

“We have to get the demand up, we have to tighten the supply a little bit before we will see any shift in prices and we haven't seen that,” said Blitzer in an interview on CNBC. But how do you tighten supply of foreclosed homes in neighborhoods that are so empty that the homes are deemed “unsellable.” Blitzer made an interesting observation:

“Periodically in studies of urban renewal, people come up with arguments that, take such and such a neighborhood, level it, fence it off for the next fifteen years until we need the land and then come back in,” said Blitzer. “That's in effect what's going to happen to some of these areas.”

Questions? Comments? [e-mail] follow me on Twitter @Diana_Olick