Should Investors Look at These Stocks on a Pullback?

Peter Dazeley | The Images Bank | Getty Images

Since the Standard & Poor's 500 touched a multi-year high on April 2, the index is down about 3.8 percent. But as Street Signshost Brian Sullivan pointed out on Monday, stocks have had much steeper pullbacks in recent years.

For instance, the S&P 500 last year dropped 253 points, or 18 percent, from July 8 to October 3. And from April 30, 2010 to July 2, 2010, the S&P 500 fell 155 points, or 13 percent.

By pullback standards, however, the S&P 500’s recent slide —Wednesday’s gains aside— is small in comparison.

“I am more bullish than the market appears,” Alpesh Patel, director of Praefinium Partners, told CNBC.

He also pointed out, “Back to back gains in the S&P 500 in the first two months of the year have occurred in 24 of the last 66 years. The average gain during those 24 years was 19.4 percent, with not a single down year.”

Here’s another case for the bulls and the idea of long-term investing.

CNBC's Analytics team ran a screen for the top-performing S&P 500 stocks since April 30, 2010 — stocks that weathered the aforementioned pullbacks and many others since then.

Percent Changes From April 2010

FOSL Fossil Inc 135.63 248.1% Consumer Discretionary
CMG Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc 425.4 215.3% Consumer Discretionary
PCLN Inc 750 186.2% Consumer Discretionary
EP El Paso Corp 29.88 146.9% Energy
AAPL Apple Inc 633.78 142.7% Information Technology
BIIB Biogen Idec Inc 126.65 137.7% Health Care
DLTR Dollar Tree Inc 94.24 132.8% Consumer Discretionary
TDC Teradata Corp 67.72 133.0% Information Technology
SBUX Starbucks Corp 57.725 122.2% Consumer Discretionary
CF CF Industries Holdings Inc 182.44 118.0% Materials

As expected, the list includes some highfliers including Priceline and Apple , and Chipotle.

But the list also includes such names as Dollar Tree and Starbucks that have shown stable growth trends.

So, should investors be looking at these types of names on a pullback?

“Granted they’ve been great over two years, if the macro picture really falls apart the exit could be very crowded,” Steve Massocca, senior vice president at Wedbush Securities, told Street Signs.

He believes dividend-paying companies are a better place to be. “There are over 650 U.S.-listed stocks that yield 5 percent or greater...You get paid to wait for the stock prices to rise.”

Massocca likes American Capital Agency in the mortgage REIT space — currently yielding 16.8 percent. He also likes Natural Resource Partners , a master limited partnership, which is currently yielding 9.4 percent.