"We don't want to be making an announcement once every few years," Goldstein said.
The Eastern Massachusetts group will be joining at least two other councils, both in California, in raising prices this year.
Read MoreCookie biz specializes in midnight munchies
But these groups aren't the first to breach the $5 mark. Girl Scouts in high cost-of-living areas such as California and Hawaii were already offering $5 cookies.
Before this season's increase, the Girl Scouts of California's Central Coast had not boosted prices in a decade, wrote Tammy Gentry, its vice president of marketing, in an email.
"The council sees the increase as an opportunity to offset natural price increases for running the cookie program — from the cost of raw materials and bakery production to transportation," Gentry said.
About 70 percent of proceeds go to the councils and the troops while the remainder goes to the baker, Gentry said.
The Girl Scouts San Gorgonio Council in California debated an increase since 2013, but made the move ahead of the 2016 season. The increase to $5 from $4 is its first since 2004.
With these two councils' decision, all of California will be at the $5 mark, wrote Elizabeth Locke-Thomas, the council's executive vice president, in an email.
Read MoreLast call for alcohol? These bars are closing fast
Maintaining the $4 price point was something the council just could not do any longer, "as the cost of the cookies from our distributor continues to rise as does infrastructure costs and, most importantly, programmatic costs," said Locke-Thomas.
While the 25 percent hike might seem steep, it is actually smaller than overall cookie inflation. Since 2004, cookies prices have jumped 32 percent, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.