Things went from counterintuitive to completely crazy when Cramer saw what stocks rallied as oil spiked. There were colossal gains in consumer spending stocks like retailers, restaurants and travel and leisure stocks. The ultimate lunacy was when Cramer saw the airlines and cruise ship stocks rally.
What do all of these stocks have in common? Their earnings go up when the price of gasoline goes down.
Read more from Mad Money with Jim Cramer
Cramer Remix: Dow is on life support—economy next?
Cramer: Oil's ugly price war just got worse
Cramer: That sell-off wasn't hideous enough
"The big portfolio managers who buy stocks in bulk have collectively decided that as oil goes, so goes the economy. If oil is headed south and south fast, that means we are going into a recession and all of these earnings for restaurants, travel, leisure and retailers will be annihilated," Cramer said.
Cramer speculated that money managers refuse to pay up for a stock like the airlines if they think the U.S. is headed into a recession. But if oil can bounce that made them think there was no recession in sight, so they loaded up on this group.
Ultimately, the buyers of these stocks refuse to accept the idea that the price of oil has gone down because there is too much supply. They believe that oil's decline is all about the lack of demand.
Of course, the rally for these stocks can be reversed if oil goes back down. And it might sound totally ridiculous that the same companies that benefit from lower oil prices are the strongest performers, but Cramer disagrees.
"I'm simply saying nope; they are rallying because when oil goes higher, this market's clinically depressed mind starts to believe that the consumer might live to spend another day instead of being mired in the coming Chinese-inspired, Fed-induced recession," Cramer said.
Ultimately, it is the fear of a recession trumps the benefits of lower oil prices in the stock market.