More Videos
- Cisco Jumps; Rest of Market to Follow?
- Call It 'Microsoft Math'
- Intel in the Anti-Trust Crosshairs, but Why?
- Apple Apps—Now More Than 100K
- WoW Fights New Front in China
- Smart Phone Competition Heats Up. Again.
- A Tale of Two Smart Phone Makers
- Avatar Hype Soars Thanks to Tech
- AMD's Ruiz Gets Tripped by Idle Chit-Chat
- Amazon is to eBay What Google is to Yahoo
MOST SHARED
- US Becomes Top Country Brand Under Obama: Survey
- BofA Board in Civil War Over Lewis' Succesor
- Obama Delays Start of Asia Trip to Attend Memorial
- Sweeping Health Care Overhaul Bill Passes House
- Framed for Porn – By a PC Virus
- What Stocks to Buy Amid Health Care Overhaul: Strategist
- Kraft to Formalize Hostile Cadbury Bid on Monday
- GE, Comcast Agree on NBC Universal Valuation
- Tamminen: Why Does Oklahoma Want To Drown New York?
- Food Network, HGTV Drive Scripps Networks' Upside Surprise
- Tommy Lee, Medical Tourism and Nasty Santa, Your Emails
- U.S. Markets Gain 3% for the Week Despite 10.2% Unemployment
- Disney's 'Carol' Tests Widest 3-D Release Ever
- Stimulus II? Jobs Tax Credit=Cash For Clunkers
- Rockwell Automation Earnings: What Options Are Saying
- Gold Will Touch Higher Lows and Higher Highs: Analyst
- Is Misery Alive And Well in Your Office?
- China to Raise Fuel Prices on Monday
- Goldman Sachs Head Says Banks Do 'God's Work'
- Fed's Bullard: Tighten Only When Recovery's 'Solid'
- Bankers Are Like Domino's Pizza Franchises: Expert
- Kraft to Formalize Hostile Cadbury Bid on Monday
- GE, Comcast Agree on NBC Universal Valuation
- Hottest Zip Codes for Home Prices
- US Home Values Follow Sales Higher, For Some
- China Urges US to Control Deficit to Stabilize Dollar
RSS FEED
Tech Check
Text Size 
Apple's [AAPL
Loading...
()
] annual shareholder meeting was short on news, but long on drama with several investors grilling the Apple directors who did show up with questions about the stock options backdating scandal.
Apple's entire directors' slate was re-elected, as expected. None of the shareholder resolutions passed, as expected.
The fireworks and interesting nuggets came during the shareholder question-and-answer session.
One of the more interesting exchanges occurred when one shareholder asked how Apple determined whether it would split the stock, a big issue as shares trade north of $100 and at an all-time high. Jobs pointed to the examples of Berkshire-Hathaway and Google [GOOG
Loading...
()
] as the arguments against a stock split. (Google's Eric Schmidt sits on Apple's board). That exchange led Piper Jaffray's Gene Munster to tell me that a split now appears less likely. Earlier in the day, he had told me a split would happen with 90% certainty.
One investor, representing big labor (AFL-CIO) peppered Jobs about whether he intended to return the suspect stock options. When he was presenting his resolution on compensation reform, he tried to ask a question of Jobs, but was silenced. So when he got his chance at the mike later, he seized upon it.
"I'm a little anxious," he told Jobs.
But Jobs was clear: the options granted to him in August of 2001 were actually priced "higher" when they were awarded the following October. "I didn't ask the Board to reimburse me," he said.
Regarding former CFO Fred Anderson (who settled the SEC investigation into his role in the options in the options backdating scandal, and then accused Jobs of misleading him), Jobs said, "Fred Anderson is an awfully good guy. I thought his comments were a little wrong." Jobs then read, and then re-read the SEC statement essentially absolving Apple of any wrongdoing, and commending the company for its cooperation in the investigation.
"Unless you think there's a conspiracy involving the SEC too, I'm not sure what else to say," said Jobs.
One shareholder wanted to know the formula used to determine Jobs' compensation. Said Jobs: "I make a dollar a year. Fifty cents for just showing up; the other 50 cents is based on performance." The crowd cheered.
He also reserved some choice comments for environmental groups, including Greenpeace, who've been dogging the company over recycling practices. Jobs took steps last week to improve Apple's standing and many resolutions about the topic were withdrawn before today's meeting.
Still, Jobs was quite vocal in criticizing these groups for their reliance on "glorified principles" instead of on scientific facts of any kind. The two sides apparently agreed to disagree, with Apple saying environmental initiatives are now a top priority.
Shareholder Scott Adams complained that only a few directors showed up to the meeting today: Google's Eric Schmidt, Intuit's [INTU
Loading...
()
] Bill Campbell, Dr. Arthur Levinson and Jobs. Adams said he knew the kinds of excuses he used to get out of work, or the ones his kids used to get out of school, and he was curious about what excuses work for directors to miss a meeting like this.
Jobs brushed off the criticism saying he holds the entire board in the highest esteem.
Finally, another shareholder recognized that Apple's R&D budget is steadily declining, now 4% of revenue. And he worried that major revenue-generating projects could be delayed, or missed all together. He pointed to the delay in Apple's next-generation operating system Leopard as an example. Jobs said research is a lot more about people and quality engineers than it is about the money.
"I wish developing great products was as easy as writing a check," said Jobs. "If that were the case, Microsoft [MSFT
Loading...
()
] would have some great products."
And the crowd cheered again.
Questions? Comments?
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes