![]()
- Japan Third Quarter GDP Jumps; 2010 Growth May Slow
- Analysis: APEC Nations Back Face-Saving Climate Plan
- Shift Into High-Quality Stocks Could Move Market Higher
- Drug Study Questions Effectiveness of Merck's Drugs
- Military Arms Race Dominates Dubai Air Show
- Buffett: I Haven't Bought AMEX Shares in Years
- Disaster Film '2012' Drowns Rivals at Box Office
- Cities With the Most Home Price Reductions
- Cramer: 5 Earnings Reports to Watch Next Week
- CNBC Video: Warren Buffett & Bill Gates - Keeping American Great
- U.S. Stocks Rally for the Second Straight Week
- Dollar is Not Plunging—So 'Calm Down': Market Strategist
- Strategists Say Markets Have More Upside — But How Much?
- Hirschhorn: Risk-Averse Traders
- Roginsky: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Financial Reform
- This Year's Biggest Thanksgiving Leftover: Cash
- TV Series Inks Unique Deal For Fight
- First Time Buyers Rescue Housing: Realtors
MOST SHARED
- U.S. May Wind Up Green With Envy
- Japan Third Quarter GDP Jumps; 2010 Growth May Slow
- Warren Buffett to CNBC: 'I Haven't Bought American Express In Years'
- Analysis: APEC Nations Back Face-Saving Climate Plan
- The Cost of Thanksgiving Dinner 2009
- Dipping Into Green Investing
- For Investors, The New Green Looks To Be White
- Disaster Film '2012' Drowns Rivals at Box Office
- CNBC Video: Warren Buffett & Bill Gates - Keeping American Great
- Sustainability Indices Sprouting Up
The continued surge in energy prices — including record highs for oil — is once again giving market speculation a bad name.
![]() |
Mark Lennihan / AP Traders buy and sell crude oil futures contracts at the New York Mercantile Exchange. |
But for all the public agitation over higher prices — which is getting more regular air time at Congressional hearings — most analysts are skeptical about any significant changes in energy trading regulations, especially oil, a thoroughly globalized commodity.
Trying to regulate oil trading now would be “like trying to go after the dog for baying at the moon. The moon is still going to be there. Traders will just move offshore,” said Philip Verleger, an industry consultant.
But natural gas, which is more of a domestic commodity, might be a different story.
In December, the Senate unanimously voted to close the so-called “Enron loophole,” which exempted large electronic trading from government scrutiny.
That sleight of hand, passed in 2000, resulted in an irrational regulatory bifurcation. The New York Mercantile Exchange (Nymex) remained a regulated exchange, but left newer, fully electronic energy exchanges, such as Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), to operate with virtually no oversight or even obligation to prevent excessive speculation.
This was the regulatory gap that the Amaranth Advisers hedge fund exploited to corner the natural gas market before vaporizing in losses of $6.6 billion in September 2006. When Nymex told Amaranth to reduce its positions, the hedge fund simply shifted them to ICE.
“It’s past time to put the cop back on the beat in US energy markets [in order] to stop price manipulation and excessive speculation,” says sponsor Senator Carl Levin about the hard-fought measure which was adopted Dec. 12. Its adoption is tied to the Farm Bill, which has a deadline for passage on April 18.
The legislation is a carefully crafted compromise worked out with industry and is not expected to immediately wring much speculation from the market but it does provides the basis for tightening oversight later on.
Populist Pressure Growing from Energy Users
For Paul Cicio, of the Industrial Energy Consumers of America (IECA), if this measure does pass it would be just a “first step” in a longer effort to curb soaring gas prices that ricochet into higher electricity prices.
The unregulated ICE has been steadily taking market share from Nymex and he estimated it probably now handles 75 to 80 percent of natural gas contracts.
Cicio is among the increasingly vocal interests demanding price-ramping speculation be curbed in energy markets for both oil and gas and their deriatiives.
“Supply and demand does not matter at all when it comes to energy commodities, it’s all about how much money is being dumped into these commodities,” said Sean Cota, of the Petroleum Marketers Association of America, which represents retailers who sell half the country’s gasoline and 80 percent of its heating oil.
“From my perspective it’s like Las Vegas without the Nevada Gaming Commission,” he added. He will be testifying next week once again before Congress on the subject.
And there are Congressional allies to his cause. Current commodities law is so riddled with exemptions, exclusions and limitations, it is “extremely difficult to ensure US energy markets operate in a fair, transparent and efficient manner,” noted a 2006 Senate investigations report, which attributed $20-30 of the then-current oil price of $70 barrel oil to speculation.
- Where, what, how.
- Warren Buffett and Bill Gates spoke to Columbia students, and Buffett made the students a startling offer.
- For the chief of cable company Comcast, growth has been about making deals – generally very large deals.
- Some companies may start using insurance to shift carbon risk from their balance sheets to maybe... yours?
- The president and founder of Genesis Today wants to improve America’s health, and thinks Wal-Mart can help.
- Switzerland's privacy watchdog is taking legal action to force Google to make changes to its Street View service.













