Skip navigation
Wall Street Crisis Video Gallery
A look at who will be the winners during increased financial regulation, with Dick Bove, Rochdale Securities analyst.
Debating whether shareholders have a right to be upset over bonuses, with Nomi Prins, Demos and Nicole Gelinas, Manhatta...
Insight on Goldman wanting to reduce the size of its bonus pool, with Susanne Craig, The Wall Street Journal reporter.


Current DateTime: 05:46:20 24 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24355697
  • Runway Angels

      The superbowl of fashion shows, models walk down the runway at the 2009 Victoria's Secret Show.

  • Smartphone Guide

      Here's a need-to-know guide to nine devices, based on features, price, network and platform.

  • Wines for the Holidays

      Not quite sure what wine to pair with Turkey or Creme Brulee? Our experts do.

FEATURED QUIZZES


Current DateTime: 05:46:20 24 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 33793611
  • A Healthier & Wealthier You

      Take the following quiz and find out how much you know about the impact of obesity on the health of the U.S. economy.

  • The Billionaire BFF's

      Philanthropists. Bridge partners. Hockey players. Which responses are based on facts from Buffett's and Gates' real lives?

  • The Many Myths of Coca-Cola

      Can you tell which statements are true, and which ones are just rumors?


Current DateTime: 05:46:20 24 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24890560
  • Winterizing Your Portfolio

      If 2009 was the winter of our discontent, will 2010 be a winter wonderland for investors? A lot depends on the recovery—or lack thereof.

  • Investor's Guide to Real Estate

      Some even say the long-awaited recovery is here. Regardless, buyers and sellers alike can profit from our guide.

  • Alternative Investing

      Stocks and bonds? Sure. But it's a big world out there for investors.

powered by digg
This Crisis Makes S&L Bailout Look Easy
By: Albert Bozzo, Senior Features Editor | 21 Sep 2008 | 01:12 PM ET
Text Size

The Bush Administration's $700 billion financial rescue plan bears little resemblance to the government’s handling of the savings-and-loan-crisis almost two decades ago—and may not be as successful, experts say.

The plan, which is still being hammered out with Congress, raises a number of red flags. First and foremost, unlike the process then, there’s no accompanying re-regulation of the financial services industry.

  • Rescue Plan Goes to Congress
  • Read Treasury's Fact Sheet on Bailout
  • Wall Street May Manage Own Bad Debt
  • "We educated ourselves enough — we were able to build a competent structure,” says Donald Riegle, who chaired the Senate’s Banking Committee at the time. "We built a legislative package that worked quite well. Firrea (Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act) included creation of a regulator as well as the RTC.”

    Though history shows the S&L crisis was resolved successfully, there was considerable skepticism about the FIRREA  law, the new regulator it created, the Office of Thrift Supervision, and the bailout entity, the Resolution Trust Corp., at the time of their creation.

    It also wound up costing less than many expected.

    In the current rescue plan, the absence of regulatory reform is no small matter, given the size of the problem and the complexity of investment instruments today.

    For Investors

    “It isn't just a question of the clean up,” says Riegle, now chairman of APCO Worldwide's government relations team. “You have to figure out how this happened and how you keep it from happening again. What are the standards for the future?"

    The regulatory and oversight shortcomings also illustrate the federal government’s patchwork approach to the problem prior to the more draconian bailout package. The Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, Fannie Mae-Freddie-Mac, AIG cases were also handled differently.

    Former S&L regulator and White House economist Lawrence White says that in the current environment if federal money is going to be at risk then the government needs regulatory tools to limit exposure, what he calls a safety-and-soundness regime for investment banks.

    “Minimal capital requirements, limitations on activities that may be too risky, managerial competency requirements, and clear powers of receivership for an insolvent institution,”  says White, now a professor at NYU's Stern School of Business.

    In the S&L crisis, the government had those powers, before and after the bailout legislation, and are considered a key part of the success.

    Failing S&Ls were seized, depositors' money protected and assets then sold off with the institution ultimately being shut down.
    Wall Street in CrisisWALL STREET IN CRISIS - A CNBC SPECIAL REPORT

    Another key difference is the size and complexity of the problem and the proposed solution— an initial $700 billion versus the estimated $145 billion price tag for the S&L rescue.

    Riegle says the problem and solution “dwarf the RTC” and are “a lot less plain vanilla.”

    “We're not talking bricks and mortar, we're talking about financial instruments, “ says Tom McMillen, a key player in the House of Representatives during the S&L saga.

    Banking analyst Bert Ely adds that the RTC “dealt with both good and bad assets."

    Dealing with the assets—from pricing to disposal—will be tricky business, whether the government holds them or sells them, say S&L veterans.

    One of the keys to the success of the S&L unwinding was an “orderly liquidation,” says McMillen, now chairman and CEO of Homeland Security Capital.

    Otherwise, it’s “like taking a whole block of houses and selling at once, which is not a way to get the best price.”

    The private asset managers controlling funds under the plan would presumably be competing to sell assets, which happen to be the same assets that no one wants to touch now.

    A Dumping Danger

    Robert Glauber, a top Treasury official who played a key role in the S&L unwinding, says the government will “be under pressure to buy and hold the assets because the argument will be that rapid dumping will crater the market for mortgage-based securities. Worse it will establish prices against which other institutions holding similar assets will have to take marks that will impair their capital.”

    Glauber says there was criticism of the RTC at the time that it “damaged the market by dumping assets," even though it did a good job.

    “The RTC decided it had to sell real estate assets at whatever prices would clear the markets so that prices would bottom and start to recover,” says Glauber, now with Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government.

    That seems to be both the challenge and the goal this time around, but this market includes both conventional debt items, such as mortgages, and complex derivatives. (What should investors do? See video)

    In the S&L bailout, White notes that the government “had the benefit of an asset disposal unit already up and running at the FDIC."

    “I think we're into a world nobody understands yet,” says Riegle.“What is the asset mix?”

    White says for that reason and others pricing of troubled or undesirable assets won’t be easy. “Because they are stinky, they're probably one of a kind,” he says.

    The administration’s plan to have private firms manage the funds may also be problematic, even if — as the Treasury says — it will have "full discretion over the management of the assets as well as the exercise of any rights received in connection with the purchase of the assets" and it can hold them as long as it likes.

    Similar proposals to subcontract some of the work at the time of the S&L rescue drew criticism on Capitol Hill.

    There were also major concerns about potential fraud and other wrongdoing given the size of the undertaking, which, to the surprise of many, never materialized.

    In the end, the government wound up using private sector contractors for asset disposals, which McMillen called “very helpful.” But they were also working in more of a local-market basis, not a national, never mind global one.

    In this case, critics could say the idea is like tipping the person you’re bailing out for a job poorly done.

    “You're asking the public to write a giant check, you obviously want an elite public interest team working the problem, says Riegle, who adds the government could and probably should hire “people from that sector and work in a public situation.”

    For all their criticism, Riegle and others agree that the current crisis has emergency situation qualities that the S&L bailout did not, so swift action — like it or not — is wise and necessary.

    Riegle says under normal circumstances, public hearings would be a necessity because something of this scale “cannot be done behind closed doors.”

    There may not be that luxury of time, even if better —  or different — crisis management might have provided that. The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, for instance, proposed a somewhat similar approach in April.

    “I think speed is really important.” Says McMillen

    © 2009 CNBC.com
    Tools:
    Print EmailAdd This share icon
    • digg share

    CNBC HIGHLIGHTS

    • A diet high in fat and sugar might actually be good for your portfolio.
    • Warren Buffett and Bill Gates discuss the economy and other subjects with CNBC's Becky Quick.
    • From the AIG&T to the Merrill Lychee, Jane Wells lists this year's fashionable holiday cocktails.
    • One shopper explains why – aside from the prices – he gets up at 3am on the day after Thanksgiving to go shopping every year.
    • Congressman Ron Paul explains to Squawk Box why he’s pushing legislation to audit the Federal Reserve.
    • …you'll want to be prepared. Tips for getting the most out of the post-Thanksgiving shopping frenzy.
    ADD COMMENTS
    Remaining characters


    Current DateTime: 05:23:04 24 Nov 2009
    LinksList Documentid: 29778428

    Current DateTime: 01:02:05 24 Nov 2009
    LinksList Documentid: 29779196

    Current DateTime: 01:09:37 24 Nov 2009
    LinksList Documentid: 29779199

    Current DateTime: 01:02:06 24 Nov 2009
    LinksList Documentid: 29779198
      Data is a real-time snapshot  *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
    Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis

    © 2009 CNBC, Inc.  All Rights Reserved.
    A Division of NBC Universal
    Thomson ReutersThomson Reuters