Two very well-respected Columbia University business types are floating a plan today in the op-ed pages of the Wall Street Journal that they claim will fix the housing market and the greater economy.

I agree with them that housing is at the heart of the economic tsunami that is now flooding every aspect of our economy, and that the housing market needs more of an infusion than the current legislation making its way to the House of Representatives can offer. But I also believe their fix borders on dangerous.

I don't mean any disrespect; I'm a Columbia grad myself, but Glen Hubbard and Chris Mayer are suggesting that the government somehow give everyone a mortgage with a 5.25 percent interest rate, and for those who are underwater on their loans (house is worth less than the loan), new mortgages would be made of up 95% of the current value of a home.

They don't say the government would decide who gets this historically low interest rate refi, but I'm guessing it's whoever is delinquent on their loan. But here's one problem: A lot of the folks who are delinquent can't afford a 5.25 percent interest rate. The only reason they could buy their overpriced homes in the first place was because they got ridiculously low teaser rates, with no money down. They were paying perhaps as low as 3% for a time before the loan adjusted.

The authors also suggest that this would be relatively simple, since the government took over Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and therefore own so many of the loans already. But what about the loans that F and F don't own. Many of those are the ones that were packaged and sold to investors. And then what about the jumbo issue? They don't seem to address that.

Jumbo loans are going into foreclosure now as well, bringing down the high end of the market right along with the low end. But I suppose the theory is that if you had enough money to get into a jumbo, then you don't deserve to be bailed out for your bad decisions as much as someone who made the same bad decision on a lower-priced home.

Then there's the part of the article which says, "For borrowers with lower credit scores, the mortgage rate would be greater than 5.25%, but it would be less than their current rate."

Well, but it's the borrowers with lower credit scores who are in the most trouble, and who can't afford the higher rate (precisely why the FHA Hope For Homeowners program isn't producing the results that were originally expected).

And lastly, the authors say that investors and speculators would not be allowed to participate in this program. Once again, punishing those who chose real estate as an investment, as so many others have throughout history and as so many others do in so many other sectors of the economy.

• Credit Crisis Hitting Home: 'Everybody Cries Together'

A home is an investment. Yes, it's a place to live, but it has also delivered steady returns to Americans for decades. The proposal by Mr.'s Mayer and Hubbard sounds plausible at face value, but it essentially nationalizes the housing market, punishing those who chose to recognize real estate as an investment and preventing homeowners from refinancing their homes in the future, which has been a major source of wealth generation over time. I'm not advocating using our homes as ATMs the way we have over the last decade, but home price appreciation and the ensuing home equity withdrawals do fuel the greater economy.

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Let the housing market correct. There is pent-up demand and that demand will, in time, absorb excess inventory, as long as the greater economy doesn't go into free fall (and I'm sorry but I can't guarantee that won't happen).

Yes, there needs to be more government money directed at saving some borrowers from some foreclosures, but not a blanket one-size-fits-all interest rate for everyone that teaches no one the lessons of overindulgence and blatant inattention to simple investment basics.

• Billionaire Ross Outlines Alternative Bailout Plan

Questions?  Comments? 

POPULAR REALTY CHECK POSTS

• 

• Own vs. Rent Riles Government Housing Policy 

• 

• States Sign On to Foreclosure ‘Robo’ Settlement 

• 

• US Treasury Forcing Mortgage Principal Forgiveness 

COMMENTS

More Comments

 

« First | « Previous

Next » | Last »

Thank you for joining our discussion. Your comment has been posted.

ADD COMMENTS

Please Sign In or Register to participate.

In order to add a comment you must click here and accept our terms and conditions.

Edit Screen Name

Please sign-in/optin or register to be able to submit comments.

Remaining characters

CNBC welcomes your contribution. Please respect our community and the integrity of its participants. CNBC reserves the right to moderate and approve your comment.

Sorry, we are no longer accepting comments.

PREVIEW COMMENT

Your comments have not been posted yet.
Please review your submission to make sure you are comfortable with your entry.

Your Comments: