Commentary: No 'Compassionate Lending' Please

Michelle Caruso-Cabrera, CNBC Anchor
Wednesday, 11 Feb 2009 | 9:04 PM ET

Did you watch the the hearings held on Wednesday? Isn’t Congress stupid?

Jones on Credit Cards
Rep. Walter Jones (R-NC) angles for better credit card rates with bank CEOs on Capitol Hill.

To wit: Representative Walter Jones, Republican of North Carolina who lit into Citigroup CEO Vikram Pandit.

(You can see him gesticulating madly in this video)

"Couldn’t there be a period of time that you would say to the American credit card holder, no longer am I going to ask you to pay 24 percent so I can make billions of dollars? What I'm gonna do for the American people is say, 9 percent. Why can’t you do something like that?"

"Have some compassion, because the majority of the people are not a member of the country club."

Vikram Pandit testifying before House Financial Services Committee
Vikram Pandit testifying before House Financial Services Committee

Once again, a member of congress equates running a business well, with a lack of compassion. Nothing could be further from the truth. The most compassionate businesses are the best-run businesses. Think of this way, if the banks had been well run from the beginning, we wouldn’t be here, right? Giving away cheap money is what got us here. Does the current situation feel “compassionate” to you?

In fact, I think raising interest rates on credit cards is the most compassionate thing Vikram Pandit can do right now.

What if you ran a pizza parlor and your flour, cheese, and tomato sauce prices went up dramatically? What if your costs went up so sharply, that when you sold a slice of pizza, you actually lost money? You’d probably raise your prices or stop selling pizza.

This is a bit of an oversimplification, but Citigroup is no different than that hypothetical pizza parlor. Its costs of credit have gone up dramatically. They used to be able to borrow money very cheaply, and, in turn, lend it out to consumers.

Now, because of the credit crunch, the cost of credit has gone through the roof. Pandit, along with everyone else needs to raise the bank’s rates to cover their cost of borrowing. In addition, with the economy so weak, defaults are rising to record levels. He needs a cushion to cover losses he knows are going to come due to non-payments. He’s ensuring future profits (Finally. Something he should have been doing long ago.)

And here’s what Representative Jones seems to forget. Because there is so much taxpayer money in Citigroup, you, me, and everyone else in America are now shareholders. So Representative Jones wants Pandit to make money-losing-credit-card loans? WITH MY TAXPAYER MONEY? Guess he’s not interested in the taxpayer getting his or her money back.

Don’t get me wrong, Vikram Pandit has obviously made huge mistakes. The list of “should-haves” is so very long. And Citigroup , along with Bank of America , Morgan Stanley , Goldman Sachs , and JP Morgan , have been given a huge gift to save them, and the system, from their mistakes.

Frankly, I think they deserve some humiliation and I’ll be the first to admit I watched with a little bit of glee as they were raked over the coals. But members of congress need to remember that jaw-boning banks into giving away loans at a loss is also a huge mistake. It won’t help their constituents, it will hurt them.

  Price   Change %Change


Contact U.S. News


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    › Learn More

Don't Miss

U.S. Video

  • Bitcoin. Digital gold rush or a shadowy tool empowering criminals on the dark web? What is really driving The Bitcoin Uprising? CNBC's Mary Thompson takes an in-depth look at this emerging digital currency by speaking to the bitcoin faithful, who believe the open source currency will upend the global financial system, as well as those who believe bitcoin is an easily manipulated tool that empowers criminals, hackers and drug barons in the dark online underworld. Although the future of bitcoin is uncertain, The Bitcoin Uprising sheds much needed light on the speculative currency and the future of money.

  • Loyalists around the world have embraced it as the cryptocurrency of the future, but some big names on the street differ widely in their beliefs about bitcoin. The Oracle of Omaha thinks it's a "joke." Tech entrepreneur Marc Andreessen counters that Buffett is out of touch, while bitcoin believers like Jonathan Rumion fully embrace the digital currency by buying groceries with bitcoin and even getting paid in bitcoin. CNBC's Mary Thompson reports.

  • Authorities say the online black-market bazaar Silk Road could be the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the criminal underworld using bitcoin for trading in illicit goods and services. On the "Dark Web," fake IDs, drugs, even hit men are all paid in bitcoin. CNBC's Mary Thompson explores why bitcoin is the currency of choice for criminal activity on the dark web and reports on the story of Mt. Gox, the largest bitcoin exchange, which shut down in February, leaving bitcoin investors holding the bag.