- Bankruptcies Jump, Hitting Highest Level in Four Years
- AIG, Ex-CEO Greenberg Reach Pact to Settle Disputes
- Bank of America CEO Search May Extend Into 2010
- Steepest Black Friday Discounts, Revealed
- 'Cancer of Fraud' Permeates Health Care System: Critics
- US Mint to Suspend American Eagle Gold 1-Ounce Coins
- Judge Erases Couple's $525,000 Mortgage Payment
- Where Do Pardoned Turkeys Go?
- For Many in US, It Will Be a Scaled-Down Holiday Season
- 4 Thanksgiving Week Buys For Your Portfolio: Market Pros
- There's a 'Great Chance' For a Double-Dip Recession: Strategist
- Revenge of the Gangsta Nerds
- Will TCU See The "Flutie Effect?"
- Retail Earnings and Sales to Improve in Q4: Analyst
- Consumers Catching the Holiday Spirit
- It's Beginning To Look A Lot More Riskless
- Crescenzi: Claims Level Suggests End to Job Losses
- Hedge Funds Take Early Lead in Warren Buffett's 'Big Bet'
MOST SHARED
- The Executive Job Search
- S&P Stocks Trading at New 52-Week Highs
- Judge Erases Couple's $525,000 Mortgage Payment
- Where Do Pardoned Turkeys Go?
- Activision Prepares to Double Dip on ‘Modern Warfare 2’
- US Mint to Suspend American Eagle Gold 1-Ounce Coins
- Salvation Army's Kettles Now Credit Card-Ready
- Foreign Demand Boosts US 7-Year Treasury Sale
- Black Friday: Can Banks Tap the Frenzy, Too?
- Oil Friday
Text Size 
CNBC.com
A recent court ruling that forced two ratings companies to defend fraud claims is a "game-changer" for the industry, David Einhorn, head of Greenlight Capital, told CNBC.
 |
CNBC |
Einhorn, a longtime critic of ratings agencies and an investor famed for calling the implosion of Lehman Brothers last year, said in a live interview that the ruling could cripple ratings companies that may not have the capital to defend against future claims.
In a case lodged against Moody's [MCO
Loading...
()
] and McGraw-Hill's [MHP
Loading...
()
] Standard & Poor's Ratings Services, a federal judge last week said the ratings of securities distributed to a limited number of investors do not have the same constitutional protections as ratings distributed more widely.
The ruling is significant, Einhorn said, in that it will help shed light on what he considered the reckless way in which ratings companies were evaluating securities and the role that played in bursting the subprime mortgage bubble. The ratings companies said their opinions were protected by the First Amendment.
"Because they violated the trust by loosening standards and concentrated on their fees and their shares, there were ... securities that were created and sold that shouldn't have been and the ratings agencies knew that at the time," he said.
"The result was that people lent money that shouldn't have lent and other people borrowed money that they couldn't repay, and now the whole thing has collapsed and our government has had to pledge really trillions of dollars to bail out the financial system."
Einhorn said he is short both Moody's and McGraw-Hill, meaning he expects both stocks to lose share price. The companies were both lower Tuesday, though some analysts immediately after the ruling said any dips in the shares could represent buying opportunities. Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway [BRKA
Loading...
()
] trimmed its position in Moody's for the second time since July.
In an earlier CNBC interview, McGraw-Hill President Harold "Terry" McGraw rebutted criticisms of the ratings agencies, pointing out that the judge actually rejected 10 of the 11 claims in the suit. He said the company will defend itself against the lone remaining claim.
"We look forward to getting that one cleared up," McGraw said on CNBC. "Fraud does not live in our house."
He acknowledged that his firm missed the housing collapse but said changes in the business model and regulations will help avoid such mistakes in the future.
"We had the housing recession wrong. The fact that a lot of other people had it wrong doesn't help, but we don't like that," McGraw said. "That's where our problems began."
- For nearly three decades, these on-call experts have been dishing advice on how to – and not to – cook turkey.
- Eric Schmidt pledges to create a virtual copy of the Iraq National Museum at Google’s expense.
- Bill Griffeth is taking a leave of absence from CNBC and Power Lunch for a year. Here's a message from Bill.
- More shoppers than ever plan to comparison-shop this season. Who will benefit?
- It may be the most unusual guide to business you'll read.
- How can you get out of debt and back on the road to recovery? Follow these ten steps.
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes