Wine Industry In The...Red
If you love wine, it's a very good year. Not only is the vintage coming out of California expected to be excellent, but prices have collapsed. You can get good wine for cheap.
"This, I think, is a major correction that's happened," says Richard Sanford of Alma Rosa Winery & Vineyards. His grapevines are tucked in the Santa Rita Hills of Santa Ynez, the central coast region made famous in the film "Sideways". Sanford planted his first vineyard 40 years ago. He'd come back from Vietnam and decided to do something a little more uplifting. Sanford studied the topography up and down California and decided that the Santa Rita hills, a range that moves west to east instead of north to south, might provide the best equivalent to Burgundy, France. It took a while to get people to believe him, especially investors. But these days, Pinot Noir from the area commands a high price.
Or it did.
Now the world is swimming in wine as people are trading down, or just not buying at all, and higher priced wines are gathering dust unless they go on sale.
"I think we're going to see a lot more Two Buck Chucks hitting the market," says John Krska of Krska Vineyard and Winery Management. "We have some winemakers who've skipped a whole vintage, and that's to get their warehouses caught up to sell wine." For example, Krska says high-quality Chardonnay grapes usually sell for $2,700 to $3,500 a ton. But this year, low-to-mid quality Chardonnay grapes in other parts of the state can be had for only $200 a ton. "If the wineries up north can't sell that, they're paying for tank space and the refrigeration, it's gone for a buck a gallon," to Trader Joe's.
Krska says he's been able to sell all of the grapes under his management this year, but he's a concerned about next year. "I think it's the economic woes in the background, saying 'Do we make more wine, or do we not make more?'" Even the region's vaunted Pinot Noir may come under pressure in the next few years as some already-planted vineyards start to produce a crop.
Still, there's nothing as romantic for wine lovers as being in the vineyard during harvest (said by someone who doesn't do the harvesting). I have the privilege of visiting here often, as my sister-in-law, Chris Jones, has a vineyard here with her husband, John, called Faith Vineyard. In fact, that's where I'm reporting live from today. For those of you who've always dreamed of owning a vineyard, Chris and John actually made the dream come true. John is a 747 Captain for United Airlines (his day job), while Chris is a writer. A dozen years ago, during the last real estate bust in California, they bought land in Los Olivos, down the road from Michael Jackson's Neverland estate. They planted seven acres of Sangiovese and Sauvignon Blanc.
Turns out it's a lot harder than it looks. John tweetsabout his battles against the VA, the "Vertebrate Alliance", rodents and birds and coyotes who insist on making a feed trough out of the vineyard. Chris has taken photographs and written about what it's really like in the vineyard, in a book called "One Vintage".Yes, I know, I'm plugging my sister-in-law's book, but what I love about "One Vintage" is how much it teaches me about winemaking, about how the grapes develop, as Chris also discovers that the cycle in the vineyard mirrors life.
This year, it's not so rosy in the rosé. Chris and John, like many other growers, fear their wine investment will end up in the...red. CalPERS, the nation's largest public employee pension plan, has invested $200 million over the last few years in two vineyards in Santa Ynez. Those investments have lost money.
Richard Sanford has seen many booms and busts in the wine business, but this time, he says "we're competing on a world stage with wine." Sanford says the wine business is very capital-intensive, and investors have to learn that it takes years to see a return. New money is hard to come by these days. "A lot of people are finding that there's isn't a lot of capital available," he says. "I don't think there are new operations starting out these days." Sanford feels lucky. Sales at his winery this year are ahead of 2008. "I think that quality will always shine through."
We spoke while sipping his new Pinot Noir, which he and tasting room manager Chris Burroughs were trying to describe. "Hazelnuts?" Sanford suggested. "Brambly," was Borroughs' take. "That's so good," was the best I could come up with. "I think that's the best term of all," Sanford laughed.
Questions? Comments? Funny Stories? Email firstname.lastname@example.org