Net
- Economy's Biggest Drag Right Now Is Government
- What’s This ‘Fiscal Cliff’ Anyway? Do I Need to Worry?
- What Falling Milk Prices Say About an Economic Slowdown
- Bad Day for BATS—and for High-Frequency Trading
- Obamacare, the Individual Mandate and MMT
- A Defense of Crony Capitalism
- The Buckaroo and the Demand for Money
- New York Housing Market Could Still Collapse: Analyst
- Why the Social Security Tax Fight Is Stupid
- Bringing the Poppy Back to Wall Street
- Carl Icahn Increases Stake in Chesapeake, Demands Board Seats
- Kansas City Fed President Steps Into Jamie Dimon Debate
- Where Large Banks Fail, Regionals are Succeeding: Bove
- Facebook IPO Fiasco: 10 Things Underwriters Got Wrong
- Bank of Greece Poised to Reveal Crucial Data
- Rumors of Bank Intervention Stir Euro Markets
- Last Call: Facebook Fiasco Is Heading Toward Farce
- How to Get Fired From Goldman Sachs
- Why Facebook Stock May Have Hit a Bottom
- Facebook Forecast Scandal's Big Question: Insider Trading?
- Last Call: Facebook IPO Forensic Examination Begins
- Case Against JPM Is 'Straightforward': Attorney
- JPMorgan Facing 2007 'Kitchen Sink' Times Again?
- Bill Ackman's J.C. Penney Presentation from Ira Sohn Conference
- Last Call: Facebook Finger Pointing in Full Bloom
Call: 201-735-4638
Text Message: 917-740-8477
- JPMorgan Sells Good Assets to Offset 'London Whale'
- Euro Isn’t Loved, but Few in Europe Want to Drop It: Poll
- Euro Zone Bank Safety Net Leaves Holes Unplugged
- Glitches Halt New Goldman Trade Platform
- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Its Four Biggest Banks
- Funds Cut Exposure to Euro Zone Banks
- US Markets Will Be Watching Europe—And Jobs Report
- As Irish Head to Polls, ‘No’ Voices Get Louder
- Emerging Markets to Test Lehman Lows on 'Grexit'
- Spain's Debt Costs Near Danger Level: Is Bailout Next?
Is Resolution Authority Over Before It Even Gets Going?
Text Size 
Senior Editor, CNBC.com
 |
CNBC.com |
The stunning drop in the share price of some of our financial behemoths—including Bank of America [BAC
Loading...
()
] and Citigroup [C
Loading...
()
]—earlier this week raised the question of how and what it would take to get the Resolution Authority invoked for a major financial institution. Could this be an authority that can never be invoked?
It’s almost a philosophical question: If an authority can never be invoked, does it really exist?
Dodd-Frank provides very little guidance for when regulators should begin the Resolution process. In the FDIC’s case study of how Lehman Brothers might have been treated if Resolution Authority existed in 2008, the FDIC assumes that it would have sprung into action following the failure of Bear Stearns. But this is too easy: the “triggering” event was the failure of Bear.
The real question should be whether or not the FDIC could have applied Resolution Authority to Bear. Can the FDIC act pre-emptively, before the first bailout? Or does it require a sudden, dramatic event like the failure of Bear Stearns to trigger the application of Resolution Authority?
The Lehman Brothers case study goes on to assume the senior management of Lehman would not have resisted attempts to put a resolution plan in place. But this strikes me as pure fantasy. Senior management of Lehman were in deep, deep denial about the financial condition and prospects of their firm. They never believed—right up until the very end—they would fail.
A crucial part of the FDIC assumption of cooperation by Lehman is the idea the senior management would understand that because Resolution Authority is available, there would be no hope of a bailout. Again, this strikes me as fantasy, wishful thinking. Market actors have serious doubts about the effectiveness of Resolution Authority. The senior management of giant banks no doubt still believe they can call upon the government to rescue them.
The FDIC imagines that Resolution Authority would operate much like an ordinary FDIC resolution of a standard depository bank. These begin months ahead of time. So ask yourself: if one of our biggest financial firms was going to fail, would we know this months ahead of time?
Remember that Lehman’s stock rallied in the spring of 2008 on strong demand for a secondary share offering.
Those who believe Resolution Authority can be effectively exercised need to explain what it would take for regulators to become convinced they needed to take action with respect to a company like Bank of America, Citigroup or Morgan Stanley [MS
Loading...
()
].
__________________________________________
Questions? Comments? Email us at
Follow John on Twitter @ twitter.com/Carney
Follow NetNet on Twitter @ twitter.com/CNBCnetnet
Facebook us @ www.facebook.com/NetNetCNBC
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
