21% of investors don't think they pay investing-related fees. Here's why they're wrong — and how it costs them
- Twenty-one percent of people said they don't pay fees to invest in non-retirement accounts, up from 14% in 2018, according to brokerage regulator FINRA.
- Financial services firms generally don't require customers to write a check for things such as mutual funds or financial advice. They withdraw their fees from your investment assets each year.
- Fees can add up significantly over time.
More than a fifth of investors don't think they pay any fees for their investment accounts, an industry survey has found. Most of them, however, are likely wrong — and that knowledge gap could cost them big money in the long term.
To that point, 21% of people said they don't pay fees to invest in non-retirement accounts, according to the Investors in the United States: The Changing Landscape survey conducted by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Investor Education Foundation.
That share is up from 14% in 2018, the last time FINRA, a self-regulatory organization that regulates member brokerage firms and exchange markets, conducted its national investor poll.
An additional 17% of investors in the recent poll said they didn't know how much they paid in fees.
More from Personal Finance:
5 money moves for financial success in the new year
63% of Americans living paycheck to paycheck
Most employers offer a Roth 401(k). Here's who may benefit
However, the broad ecosystem of financial services companies doesn't work for free. These firms — whether an investment fund or financial advisor, for example — generally levy investment fees of some kind.
Those fees may largely be invisible to the average person. Firms disclose their fees in fine print, but generally don't ask customers to write a check or debit money from their checking accounts each month like non-financial firms might do for a subscription or utility payment.
Instead, they withdraw money behind the scenes from a customer's investment assets — charges that can easily go unnoticed.
"It's relatively frictionless," said Christine Benz, director of personal finance at Morningstar. "We're not conducting a transaction to pay for those services."
"And that makes you much less sensitive to the fees you're paying — in amount and whether you're paying fees at all."
Why tiny fees can add up to thousands over time
Investment fees are often expressed as a percentage of investors' assets, deducted annually.
Investors paid an average 0.40% fee for mutual and exchange-traded funds in 2021, according to Morningstar. This fee is also known as an "expense ratio."
That means the average investor with $10,000 would have had $40 withdrawn from their account last year. That dollar fee would rise or fall each year according to investment balance.
The percentage and dollar amount may seem innocuous, but even small variations in fees can add up significantly over time due to the power of compounding.
"You don't just lose the tiny amount of fees you pay — you also lose all the growth that money might have had for years into the future," according to Vanguard Group.
The bulk — 96% — of investors who responded to FINRA's survey noted their main motivation to invest is to make money over the long term.
The Securities and Exchange Commission has an example to demonstrate the long-term dollar impact of fees. The example assumes a $100,000 initial investment earning 4% a year for 20 years. An investor who pays a 0.25% annual fee versus one paying 1% a year would have roughly $30,000 more after two decades: $208,000 versus $179,000.
That dollar sum might well represent about a year's worth of portfolio withdrawals in retirement, give or take, for someone with a $1 million portfolio.
In all, a fund with high costs "must perform better than a low-cost fund to generate the same returns for you," the SEC said.
Fees can impact decisions such as 401(k) rollovers
Fees can have a big financial impact on common decisions such as rolling over money from a 401(k) plan into an individual retirement account.
Rollovers — which might occur after retirement or a job change, for example — play a "particularly important" role in opening traditional, or pre-tax, IRAs, according to the Investment Company Institute.
Seventy-six percent of new traditional IRAs were opened only with rollover dollars in 2018, according to ICI, an association representing regulated funds, including mutual funds, exchange-traded funds and closed-end funds.
About 37 million — or 28% — of U.S. households own traditional IRAs, holding a collective $11.8 trillion at the end of 2021, according to ICI.
But IRA investments typically carry higher fees than those in 401(k) plans. As a result, investors would lose $45.5 billion in aggregate savings to fees over 25 years, based only on rollovers conducted in 2018, according to an analysis by The Pew Charitable Trusts, a nonpartisan research organization.
Fees have fallen over time
This annual fee structure isn't necessarily the case for all investors.
For example, some financial planners have shifted to a flat-dollar fee, whether an ongoing subscription-type fee or a one-time fee for a consultation.
And some fee models are different. Investors who buy single stocks or bonds may pay a one-time upfront commission instead of an annual fee. A rare handful of investment funds may charge nothing at all; in these cases, firms are likely trying to attract customers to then cross-sell them other products that do carry a fee, said Benz of Morningstar.
Here's the good news for many investors: Even if you haven't been paying attention to fees, they've likely declined over time.
Fees for the average fund investor have fallen by half since 2001, to 0.40% from 0.87%, according to Morningstar. This is largely due to investors' preferences for low-cost funds, particularly so-called index funds, Morningstar said.
Index funds are passively managed; instead of deploying stock- or bond-picking strategies, they seek to replicate the performance of a broad market index such as the S&P 500 Index, a barometer of U.S. stock performance. They're typically less expensive than actively managed funds.
Investors paid an average 0.60% for active funds and 0.12% for index funds in 2021, according to Morningstar.
Benz recommends 0.50% as a "good upper threshold for fees." It may make sense to pay more for a specialized fund or a small fund that must charge more each year due to smaller economies of scale, Benz said.
A higher fee — say, 1% — may also be reasonable for a financial advisor, depending on the services they provide, Benz said. For 1%, which is a common fee among financial advisors, customers should expect to get services beyond investment management, such as tax management and broader financial planning.
"The good news is most advisors are indeed bundling those services together," she said.