So what is the solution? Grant says the best technique for sparking creative ideas is to instead have individuals write their thoughts on paper first, then share.
"Let people come up with ideas separately," he says. And, be sure the lists of ideas are long.
"There is some evidence that in a brain-storming exercise or a brain-writing exercise, your first 20 ideas are actually less creative than your next 15, and that if you want to max out on creativity you actually need 200 ideas on the table before you hit the highest point of novelty," Grant explains.
Successful entrepreneurs like Richard Branson have cited creativity as a key component for a prosperous business.
"Creativity is one of the cornerstones of the Virgin brand," Branson writes on his blog of his global company that spans space travel through mobile phones. "Our success has been defined by our ability to take a step back from problems, and re-imagine them to in turn see new, original solutions."
"Shark Tank" investor Kevin O'Leary even says pursuing creative hobbies like photography and guitar has made him more successful in business.
For Jeff Chapin, a co-founder and the chief product officer of direct to consumer mattress company Casper, developing new ideas is key. His best advice to be more creative is to get away from the office and interact with customers, clients or competitors.
"Get out of your desk chair," Chapin tells CNBC Make It. "You're never getting good ideas sitting behind your computer."
Like this story? Like CNBC Make It on Facebook.
Don't miss: The one question you should always ask in a job interview, according to Wharton's top professor