These college majors have the best return on investment, according to a new report
College can be an expensive investment — and the stress of choosing a school, compounded by escalating costs and the Covid-19 pandemic, can feel debilitating.
A college degree is still one of the best ways to increase your earning potential. College graduates on average earn 80% more than those with just a high school diploma. Nearly two-thirds (65%) of bachelor degree programs also enable graduates to recoup the cost of their diploma in 10 years or less, according to a new report from public policy group Third Way.
Certain majors, however, may bring a faster return on investment than others, the report found. Michael Itzkowitz, the report's author and a senior fellow for higher education at Third Way, analyzed data collected by the U.S. Department of Education from about 2.2 million students who graduated in 2015 and 2016, then measured their earnings two years later.
There are 11 bachelor's degree programs that allow most graduates to recoup the money spent on their diploma in five years or less, the report notes. Seven engineering majors dominate the list, including petroleum, aerospace and industrial engineering. The remaining majors are also in science, math and health care: nursing, dental support services, construction management and quality control/safety technicians.
Other fields, such as drama and dance, showed no return on investment most of the time, the report found. That doesn't mean those careers don't offer creative fulfillment or societal value, Itzkowitz tells CNBC Make It, but it could indicate "unstable employment or limited economic return."
He calculated the earnings premium of college graduates by comparing the average salary of those who attended college to a high school graduate, then measuring that number against the average net cost a graduate paid toward their degree (an amount that can include tuition, housing and books/supplies costs). For example: if a student graduates with a bachelor's degree in business and earns $15,000 more than a high school graduate in their field, and their degree cost $60,000, it would take four years to recoup the cost.
Itzkowitz adds that he wasn't surprised by the report's findings as workers in STEM and healthcare have historically been "high in demand." "They tend to have the strongest job prospects, so they can start earning a lot of money right after graduating," he says.
The Covid-19 pandemic led many prospective students to delay or reconsider their college plans altogether, largely due to financial concerns. Even as campuses throughout the country re-open for the fall semester, cost remains a top concern. According to a recent report by Fidelity Investments, 4 out of 10 students rank cost as the "most important" factor in choosing a school.
There's also a clear gap between the tuition payoff for public, private and for-profit school graduates. Itzkowitz found that public institutions offered the best prospects for a graduate to quickly recover their education costs: 73% of public programs saw graduates recouping their investment within 10 years, compared with 56% of private, non-profit programs and 40% of for-profit programs. As public schools are almost always less expensive than private and for-profit schools, Itzkowitz explains, public school graduates tend to recoup their investments at a quicker pace — especially if they chose a major with a high earnings premium.
Jeff Levy, an independent educational consultant in Santa Monica, warns students not to pick a major solely because of its potential salary. "There's no way of knowing, with 100% certainty, which professions will pay the best in 5, 10 years," he says.
The better way to shop for a college, Levy recommends, is to look at schools that will be the most generous given your financial profile. For example: if you're a family with clear financial need, prioritize colleges that distribute a lot of need-based aid to get the biggest financial package. If you have little to no financial need, he says, prioritize schools that are generous with merit-based aid.
But the number one tip Levy shares with all of his students is to find a vocation they're passionate about and apply to the schools that have respected programs in that field.
"The best guarantee of future success is deeply engaging in what you love," he says. "Not being in the bottom third of your accounting or engineering class because you think it will make you more money down the road."
Check out: 70% of college students say affordability impacted their fall 2021 plans
Sign up now: Get smarter about your money and career with our weekly newsletter
- 1Rihanna rented an Arizona man's house for $500,000—enough to pay off 2 years of his mortgage
- 231-year-old used her $1,200 stimulus check to start a business on track to bring in $1 million
- 310 in-demand side hustles you can do from home—some can pay as much as $100 an hour
- 4A 67-year-old American shares what retirement is 'really' like—with 'no work and all that free time'
- 5These are the 10 best states in the U.S. for a long, healthy life—California didn't make the top 5